5

Shulchan Aruch says an Israeli Jew who is just visiting non-Israel should not work in public on the second day of Yomtov so long as he is in "yishuv" (and commentaries explain "yishuv yisrael") -- a city inhabited by Jews.

I think there are places in the United States where you could draw a hundred-mile radius where you won't run into a single yomtov-observant Jew -- but you will run into Jews who don't observe. How about in those places?

  • Isn't the whole thing about breaking from the minhag hamakom? Do nonobservant Jews have a minhag? – Double AA Jul 2 '13 at 4:10
  • @double-aa but the minhag of double Yom tov is applicable to all Jews outside of arasS yisroel even they are observant or not. Yes it is minhag but it is holocho derabonon and we can't drop it until we make Aliyah or a sanhadrin comes and paskens that we don't follow this holocho any ore. – MoriDowidhYa3aqov Jul 2 '13 at 5:01
  • @MoriDoweedhYaAgob So what? – Double AA Jul 2 '13 at 6:53
  • @double-aa so this holocho has nothing to do with minhag outside of Yisroel. It is applicable to all Jews. So a frei Yid is not exempt from the law. – MoriDowidhYa3aqov Jul 2 '13 at 12:51
  • @mori so what? We're talking about the visitor not the locals. – Double AA Jul 2 '13 at 12:58
1

I asked a Rosh Kollel that question. After checking he told me a Jew living in Israel cannot go to a place where there is an organized Jewish community (I assume based on SA OC 496:3). The fact that there are isolated Jews is not an issue (luckily since, unless you go to a real desert, there is always a risk of having isolated Jews). In my case, I was able to fly to an airport in chu"l on yom tov sheni since there was no organized community there.

The same ruling would apply to your question and allow a Jew living in Israel to go the isolated places you describe.

I have now seen that R David Sperling rules in the same way here

[...] there are major rabbinic opinions that allow it. This is because when in transit you stay in the airport which is considered similar to a "desert" (ed: despite the fact there are nearly certainly individual Jews in the airport) – that is a place that does not yet obligate you to refrain from labor on second day Yom Tov (see the work Yom Tov Sheni BeHalacha, 3:11)

[...]

if you are already in a city that has a Jewish community in it (and not just passing through the airport), it is forbidden to fly out of it on second day, for it would be forbidden to drive to the airport

See also MB 496:10

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .