Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/StackJudaism/status/1417137181127331852
added 83 characters in body
Source Link
Dov
  • 34.5k
  • 3
  • 29
  • 89

Halachic dispute over Geshtuppte Ganz'Geshtuppte Ganz' (Goose Liver) - Stuffed-goose dish

I was reading the Artscroll biography of the Tosher Rebbe and it writes on p.283 the following:

He recalled how his grandfather the Saba Kadisha, had warned him against eating geshtuppte ganz, the stuffed-goose dish that was commonly eaten in Hungary. It was subject of fierce halachic dispute, and the Tosher Rebbe had held it forbidden.

The footnote there reads:

This was questionable according to halacha because the food pipe might have developed a hole, as the geese were force-fed. While many Jews would eat this dish, there were several poskim who ruled it forbidden.

DoesBuilding on the Rema as pointed out by @JoelK below, does anyone know of any sourcesources / sheilos v'teshuvos that discuss this case further?

Halachic dispute over Geshtuppte Ganz - Stuffed-goose dish

I was reading the Artscroll biography of the Tosher Rebbe and it writes on p.283 the following:

He recalled how his grandfather the Saba Kadisha, had warned him against eating geshtuppte ganz, the stuffed-goose dish that was commonly eaten in Hungary. It was subject of fierce halachic dispute, and the Tosher Rebbe had held it forbidden.

The footnote there reads:

This was questionable according to halacha because the food pipe might have developed a hole, as the geese were force-fed. While many Jews would eat this dish, there were several poskim who ruled it forbidden.

Does anyone know of any source that discuss this case?

Halachic dispute over 'Geshtuppte Ganz' (Goose Liver) - Stuffed-goose dish

I was reading the Artscroll biography of the Tosher Rebbe and it writes on p.283 the following:

He recalled how his grandfather the Saba Kadisha, had warned him against eating geshtuppte ganz, the stuffed-goose dish that was commonly eaten in Hungary. It was subject of fierce halachic dispute, and the Tosher Rebbe had held it forbidden.

The footnote there reads:

This was questionable according to halacha because the food pipe might have developed a hole, as the geese were force-fed. While many Jews would eat this dish, there were several poskim who ruled it forbidden.

Building on the Rema as pointed out by @JoelK below, does anyone know of any sources / sheilos v'teshuvos that discuss this case further?

Source Link
Dov
  • 34.5k
  • 3
  • 29
  • 89

Halachic dispute over Geshtuppte Ganz - Stuffed-goose dish

I was reading the Artscroll biography of the Tosher Rebbe and it writes on p.283 the following:

He recalled how his grandfather the Saba Kadisha, had warned him against eating geshtuppte ganz, the stuffed-goose dish that was commonly eaten in Hungary. It was subject of fierce halachic dispute, and the Tosher Rebbe had held it forbidden.

The footnote there reads:

This was questionable according to halacha because the food pipe might have developed a hole, as the geese were force-fed. While many Jews would eat this dish, there were several poskim who ruled it forbidden.

Does anyone know of any source that discuss this case?