If one skipped והוא רחום and the extra paragraphs in Tachanun on Monday and Thursday should he go back to say them if he finished Tachanun or even the rest of Davening?
2
-
judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/23490/…– Gershon GoldCommented Jan 11, 2018 at 19:26
-
@GershonGold I don't see anything in that question that is relevant to answering this one. What would be an accurate definition of poretz geder ?– DanFCommented Jan 11, 2018 at 21:17
Add a comment
|
1 Answer
See Mishnah Berura commentary #3 on O.C. 134:1. He explains that one who didn't say Vehu Rachum at all is called poretz geder - "breaching the fence".
The term poretz geder is used regarding anyone who violates a strongly established custom. Even if the environment or conditions that established a custom no longer exist, we are extremely reluctant to abolish the custom without the ruling of a Sanhedrin. This term is used selectively, and it seems that it's a fairly severe term.
While there is nothing specific in O.C. stating what to do if one accidentally skips Vehu Rachum, I think that the labeling of someone as a poretz geder would obligate him to repeat it at some point during davening.
-
-
@mevaqesh My apologies. I had the site on Friday, and I forgot to add that. It was from a book on Google books. I'll try to hunt that down.– DanFCommented Jan 14, 2018 at 1:55
-
This does not answer the question. Perhaps the question was edited later. He is asking if one should go back. Many fast minyanim simply do not allow one to say everything.– Y DJCommented Sep 17 at 12:45