5

Sfas Emes begins his commentary on Parshat Noach, according to Sefaria, by saying "I do not properly remember." All the other Parshas begin with some variation of "B'H". Why does he say this here? Is it possible the translation of Sefaria is incorrect? Sfas Emes on Parshat Noach, translated by Sefaria

1
  • 2
    Does he say anything particularly controversial or borderline heretical? Commented Sep 12 at 18:13

1 Answer 1

11

The Sfat Emet isn't originally a written composition, but rather a record of discourses that were delivered orally. So in the year 5631 he just didn't remember perfectly what he had said (understandably, since that was the first year he started recording his discourses in writing).

Here is an example of the Chatam Sofer saying the same thing (last line of his sermon for 7 Av 5560, also interestingly in the first years of recording his sermons).

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .