9

I am looking for books that deal primarily with the halachos in Orach Chaim siman 240 and Even HaEzer siman 25. Due to the nature of the content it seems that the world has been reluctant to put out books that delve into the specifics of each halacha.

2 books that I currently own and I find very helpful are Kuntres Ufakadetah Navchah written by Rabbi Fink in New York. The other is Mishkan Yisrael written by Rabbi Shlanger in Jerusalem. (And of course, the Mishna Brurah).

Are there any other books that deal with these halachos in depth?

(Suggestions about other resources that might be helpful for teaching chasan classes are also welcome.)

  • 3
    You can't learn these halachos from a book and then teach it. You have to learn it from a PERSON who will teach it according to their Mesorah. There are a lot of things even in the Mishna Berurah which are not followed nowadays as exactly written, especially in these sensitive areas of halacha. – Reb Chaim HaQoton Dec 13 '13 at 7:05
  • 2
    @RebChaimHaQoton I understand that there is alot of hashkafa that must be taught with regards to these halachos and I have been given hadracha and continue get hadracha from my Rebbi. What I'm asking for is a resource for the HALACHOS. Muttar, assur, midas chasidus etc. I'm not asking for hashkafa. – Gavriel Dec 13 '13 at 11:30
  • 3
    I was talking about both the "halachos" and the "hashfaka". – Reb Chaim HaQoton Dec 14 '13 at 16:22
  • 2
    @RebChaimHaQoton Do you have any sources for any of your claims that this is somehow a unique area of halakha that one cannot study on ones own? – mevaqesh Jun 19 '17 at 20:50
  • Everything is muter, you just need to figure out how to explain and what works for the chosson (and his future kallah.) – Yehoshua Jun 19 '17 at 21:19
17

Some of this was summarized in a previous answer here. There are many opinions about this stuff, by the way.

Rabbi Yehuda Herzl Henkin's Bnei Banim 4:16 is a MUST READ.

It addresses the halachic angle on some of these matters, while Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein's "Of Marriage: Relationship and Relations" (Tradition 39:2) addresses the "hashkafic" (philosophical) angle.

Here's some vitally important material that the Steipler Rav wrote for chassanim.

Yocheved Debow's book for parents is also important. (Especially as chosson teachers may find themselves answering questions that parents never did.)

In short, some of this was left as oral law. You'll notice that the language is different even within the Shulchan Aruch between OC240 ("how to be a very holy person") and EH25 ("how to treat your wife.") Rabbi Henkin's essay goes through some of the frustrations in trying to determine what laws on this subject were codified how and where. There are contemporary opinions that run the gamut from "everything in OC240 is absolute halacha, plus a bunch more things are assur too" to "these reflect a certain set of minhagim that may be recommended in some situations, and occasionally an ascetic philosophy that is not the right one for our time."

Personally? I recommend chasanim not read OC240. We decry how damaging inappropriate videos are to marital relationships because their focus is "whatever makes me feel good, I don't have to think of the woman as a person with her own feelings, wants, and needs"; as the Steipler letter points out, some of the ascetic material in our rabbinic literature (which as Rabbi Lichtenstein points out, leaves us perplexed where it came from) seems to say: "just do whatever gives you least pleasure so you can be holy", ignoring that there's another human being in the room with their own feelings, wants, and needs. A martyrdom attitude -- "I will try to totally ignore my wants whatsoever and only do what I think is good for the other person" -- tends not to work in normal relationships either. This has to be about two people who respect each other and work together.

  • with regards to the letter from the stiepler, R. Drezin leaves out quite a bit, including the context. full letter is in אורחות רבנו חלק אבן העזר עניני קדושה עמוד נז. I uploaded it to scribd and it can be viewed here: scribd.com/document/355734130/… – moses Aug 7 '17 at 14:03
  • note also that after the letter in אורחות רבנו the author comments that "someone" once printed this letter and left out certain points, and that the stiepler was not happy about this. it would appear that is is indeed ר׳ נחום דריזין. – moses Aug 7 '17 at 14:06
3

Rabbi Eliezer Melamed has a sefer on this topic in his Peninei Halacha Series called "שמחת הבית וברכתו". You can buy it at many Israeli seforim stores; it's harder to come by in America, but the entire book is also available online here.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .