Skip to main content
Mi Yodeya

Return to Question

Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackJudaism/status/247893345723101184
replace "goy" with "non-Jew" per http://meta.judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/1127/should-we-censor-the-term-goy-when-used-in-english-to-mean-gentile
Source Link
edit approved Sep 10, 2012 at 19:49
Charles Koppelman
edit approved Sep 10, 2012 at 19:49
Charles Koppelman
  • 6.9k
  • 1
  • 25
  • 58

Bas Cohen having relations with a goynon-Jew

It says in SA YD Siman 305 that a Bas Cohen that has a bechor (firstborn) with a goynon-Jew there is chiyuv of pidyon haben since the Bas Cohen through having relations with the goynon-Jew she looses her status of being a Bas Cohen. What about if a not-frum (irreligious) Bas Cohen before becoming a baalas teshuva (religious person) had relations with a goynon-Jew. Then after becoming frum (religious) later got married to a Yisrael and had a bechor. Is there a chiyuv of making a pidyon haben on that child? (My doubt is because through the relations with the goynon-Jew before becoming frum perhaps she lost her status of being a Bas Cohen.)

Bas Cohen having relations with a goy

It says in SA YD Siman 305 that a Bas Cohen that has a bechor (firstborn) with a goy there is chiyuv of pidyon haben since the Bas Cohen through having relations with the goy she looses her status of being a Bas Cohen. What about if a not-frum (irreligious) Bas Cohen before becoming a baalas teshuva (religious person) had relations with a goy. Then after becoming frum (religious) later got married to a Yisrael and had a bechor. Is there a chiyuv of making a pidyon haben on that child? (My doubt is because through the relations with the goy before becoming frum perhaps she lost her status of being a Bas Cohen.)

Bas Cohen having relations with a non-Jew

It says in SA YD Siman 305 that a Bas Cohen that has a bechor (firstborn) with a non-Jew there is chiyuv of pidyon haben since the Bas Cohen through having relations with the non-Jew she looses her status of being a Bas Cohen. What about if a not-frum (irreligious) Bas Cohen before becoming a baalas teshuva (religious person) had relations with a non-Jew. Then after becoming frum (religious) later got married to a Yisrael and had a bechor. Is there a chiyuv of making a pidyon haben on that child? (My doubt is because through the relations with the non-Jew before becoming frum perhaps she lost her status of being a Bas Cohen.)

added 50 characters in body; edited tags; edited tags
Source Link
msh210 ♦
msh210 ♦
  • 73.9k
  • 12
  • 122
  • 369

It says in SA YD Siman 305 that a Bas Cohen that has a bechor (firstborn) with a goy there is chiyuv of pidyon haben since the Bas Cohen through having relations with the goy she looses her status of being a Bas Cohen. What about if a not frum-frum (irreligious) Bas Cohen before becoming a baalesbaalas teshuva (religious person) had relations with a goy. Then after becoming frum (religious) later got married to a Yisrael and had a bechor. Is there a chiyuv of making a pidyon haben on that child? (the sofek being since al yadeiMy doubt is because through the relations with the goy before becoming frum perhaps she then lost her status of being a Bas Cohen.)

It says in SA YD Siman 305 that a Bas Cohen that has a bechor with a goy there is chiyuv of pidyon haben since the Bas Cohen through having relations with the goy she looses her status of being a Bas Cohen. What about if a not frum Bas Cohen before becoming a baales teshuva had relations with a goy. Then after becoming frum later got married to a Yisrael and had a bechor. Is there a chiyuv of making a pidyon haben on that child (the sofek being since al yadei the relations with the goy before becoming frum perhaps she then lost her status of being a Bas Cohen.)

It says in SA YD Siman 305 that a Bas Cohen that has a bechor (firstborn) with a goy there is chiyuv of pidyon haben since the Bas Cohen through having relations with the goy she looses her status of being a Bas Cohen. What about if a not-frum (irreligious) Bas Cohen before becoming a baalas teshuva (religious person) had relations with a goy. Then after becoming frum (religious) later got married to a Yisrael and had a bechor. Is there a chiyuv of making a pidyon haben on that child? (My doubt is because through the relations with the goy before becoming frum perhaps she lost her status of being a Bas Cohen.)

Source Link
Yehoshua
Yehoshua
  • 16.2k
  • 5
  • 27
  • 78

Bas Cohen having relations with a goy

It says in SA YD Siman 305 that a Bas Cohen that has a bechor with a goy there is chiyuv of pidyon haben since the Bas Cohen through having relations with the goy she looses her status of being a Bas Cohen. What about if a not frum Bas Cohen before becoming a baales teshuva had relations with a goy. Then after becoming frum later got married to a Yisrael and had a bechor. Is there a chiyuv of making a pidyon haben on that child (the sofek being since al yadei the relations with the goy before becoming frum perhaps she then lost her status of being a Bas Cohen.)