Skip to main content
edited body
Source Link
Seth J
  • 41.9k
  • 8
  • 90
  • 262

We all know that there is a custom on Shavuos to eat dairy. One of the reasons given is based on a Medrash that When Moshe Rabbenu whenwent up to Heaven to receive the Torah the angels complained and said "How could this Manman of flesh and blood be worthy to take the Torah?" Hashem answered that when the Malachim (angels) came to Abraham they themselves did not keep the Torah, as they ate meat and milk together. The angels accepted this answer (among others) and hence on Shavuos we eat dairy.


With that introduction here are the questions.

  1. The Torah law only does not allow cooking milk and meat together so how were the Malachim not keeping the Torah?

  2. If it was cooked together, how was Abraham allowed to feed them this mixture? Abraham kept the whole Torah, and milk and meat are Assur Bhanah (one can't have benefit from the mixture). This prohibition applies even if one wants to feed it to a non-Jew?

We all know that there is a custom on Shavuos to eat dairy. One of the reasons given is based on a Medrash that When Moshe Rabbenu when up to Heaven to receive the Torah the angels complained and said "How could this Man of flesh and blood be worthy to take the Torah?" Hashem answered that when the Malachim (angels) came to Abraham they themselves did not keep the Torah, as they ate meat and milk together. The angels accepted this answer (among others) and hence on Shavuos we eat dairy.


With that introduction here are the questions.

  1. The Torah law only does not allow cooking milk and meat together so how were the Malachim not keeping the Torah?

  2. If it was cooked together, how was Abraham allowed to feed them this mixture? Abraham kept the whole Torah, and milk and meat are Assur Bhanah (one can't have benefit from the mixture). This prohibition applies even if one wants to feed it to a non-Jew?

We all know that there is a custom on Shavuos to eat dairy. One of the reasons given is based on a Medrash that When Moshe Rabbenu went up to Heaven to receive the Torah the angels complained and said "How could this man of flesh and blood be worthy to take the Torah?" Hashem answered that when the Malachim (angels) came to Abraham they themselves did not keep the Torah, as they ate meat and milk together. The angels accepted this answer (among others) and hence on Shavuos we eat dairy.


With that introduction here are the questions.

  1. The Torah law only does not allow cooking milk and meat together so how were the Malachim not keeping the Torah?

  2. If it was cooked together, how was Abraham allowed to feed them this mixture? Abraham kept the whole Torah, and milk and meat are Assur Bhanah (one can't have benefit from the mixture). This prohibition applies even if one wants to feed it to a non-Jew?

Spelling - This is not a transliteration critique; I changed the spelling to what I think the OP intended.
Source Link
Seth J
  • 41.9k
  • 8
  • 90
  • 262

Shavous Shavuos and Malachim(angels)

We all know that there is a custom on ShavousShavuos to eat dairy. One of the reasons given is based on a Medrash that When Moshe Rabbenu when up to Heaven to receive the Torah the angels complained and said "How could this Man of flesh and blood be worthy to take the Torah?" Hashem answered that when the Malachim (angels) came to Abraham they themselves did not keep the Torah, as they ate meat and milk together. The angels accepted this answer (among others) and hence on Shavuos we eat dairy.


With that introduction here are the questions.

  1. The Torah law only does not allow cooking milk and meat together so how were the Malachim not keeping the Torah?

  2. If it was cooked together, how was Abraham allowed to feed them this mixture? Abraham kept the whole Torah, and milk and meat are Assur Bhanah (one can't have benefit from the mixture). This prohibition applies even if one wants to feed it to a non-Jew?

Shavous and Malachim(angels)

We all know that there is a custom on Shavous to eat dairy. One of the reasons given is based on a Medrash that When Moshe Rabbenu when up to Heaven to receive the Torah the angels complained and said "How could this Man of flesh and blood be worthy to take the Torah?" Hashem answered that when the Malachim (angels) came to Abraham they themselves did not keep the Torah, as they ate meat and milk together. The angels accepted this answer (among others) and hence on Shavuos we eat dairy.


With that introduction here are the questions.

  1. The Torah law only does not allow cooking milk and meat together so how were the Malachim not keeping the Torah?

  2. If it was cooked together, how was Abraham allowed to feed them this mixture? Abraham kept the whole Torah, and milk and meat are Assur Bhanah (one can't have benefit from the mixture). This prohibition applies even if one wants to feed it to a non-Jew?

Shavuos and Malachim(angels)

We all know that there is a custom on Shavuos to eat dairy. One of the reasons given is based on a Medrash that When Moshe Rabbenu when up to Heaven to receive the Torah the angels complained and said "How could this Man of flesh and blood be worthy to take the Torah?" Hashem answered that when the Malachim (angels) came to Abraham they themselves did not keep the Torah, as they ate meat and milk together. The angels accepted this answer (among others) and hence on Shavuos we eat dairy.


With that introduction here are the questions.

  1. The Torah law only does not allow cooking milk and meat together so how were the Malachim not keeping the Torah?

  2. If it was cooked together, how was Abraham allowed to feed them this mixture? Abraham kept the whole Torah, and milk and meat are Assur Bhanah (one can't have benefit from the mixture). This prohibition applies even if one wants to feed it to a non-Jew?

added 99 characters in body; edited tags
Source Link
ertert3terte
  • 40.8k
  • 7
  • 100
  • 210

We all know that there is a Minhagcustom on Shavous to eat Dairydairy.One One of the reasons given is based on a Medrash Thatthat When Moshe Rabbenu when up to Heaven to receive the Torah the angels complained and said "How could this Man of flesh and blood be worthy to take the Torah?"Thereafter" Hashem saidanswered that when the Malachim  (angels) came to Abraham they themselves did not keep the Torah, as they ate meat and milk together and they. The angels accepted this answer among many(among others) and hence on Shavuos we eat dairy.With


With that introduction here are the questions? 1)The Torah law only does not allow COOKING milk and meat together so where were the Malachim not keeping the Torah? 2)If it was Cooked together then how was Abraham allowed to feed them as we know he kept the whole Torah and Milk and Meat are Assur Bhanah(cant have pleasure) even to feed it to a Non Jew?.

  1. The Torah law only does not allow cooking milk and meat together so how were the Malachim not keeping the Torah?

  2. If it was cooked together, how was Abraham allowed to feed them this mixture? Abraham kept the whole Torah, and milk and meat are Assur Bhanah (one can't have benefit from the mixture). This prohibition applies even if one wants to feed it to a non-Jew?

We all know that there is a Minhag on Shavous to eat Dairy.One of the reasons given is based on a Medrash That When Moshe Rabbenu when up to Heaven to receive the Torah the angels complained and said "How could this Man of flesh and blood be worthy to take the Torah?"Thereafter Hashem said that when the Malachim(angels) came to Abraham they themselves did not keep the Torah as they ate meat and milk together and they accepted this answer among many and hence we eat dairy.With that introduction here are the questions? 1)The Torah law only does not allow COOKING milk and meat together so where were the Malachim not keeping the Torah? 2)If it was Cooked together then how was Abraham allowed to feed them as we know he kept the whole Torah and Milk and Meat are Assur Bhanah(cant have pleasure) even to feed it to a Non Jew?

We all know that there is a custom on Shavous to eat dairy. One of the reasons given is based on a Medrash that When Moshe Rabbenu when up to Heaven to receive the Torah the angels complained and said "How could this Man of flesh and blood be worthy to take the Torah?" Hashem answered that when the Malachim  (angels) came to Abraham they themselves did not keep the Torah, as they ate meat and milk together. The angels accepted this answer (among others) and hence on Shavuos we eat dairy.


With that introduction here are the questions.

  1. The Torah law only does not allow cooking milk and meat together so how were the Malachim not keeping the Torah?

  2. If it was cooked together, how was Abraham allowed to feed them this mixture? Abraham kept the whole Torah, and milk and meat are Assur Bhanah (one can't have benefit from the mixture). This prohibition applies even if one wants to feed it to a non-Jew?

deleted 104 characters in body
Source Link
SimchasTorah
  • 33.5k
  • 1
  • 54
  • 192
Loading
Source Link
SimchasTorah
  • 33.5k
  • 1
  • 54
  • 192
Loading