Skip to main content
added 28 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Rabbi Kaii
  • 14.1k
  • 3
  • 17
  • 71

Why did G-D allow non Jews to be born in circumstances whereby they might never have heard about the Torah

According to Rabbi Ovadiah YosefAccording to Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef, non Jews cannot do complete Teshuva, instead their Teshuva only prevents negative judgement against them in this world [SOURCE:

https://halachayomit.co.il/he/Default.aspx?HalachaID=645&PageIndex=18 ]

Furthermore, non Jews get punished for doing what they think is right without acknowledging the G-D of Israel and the Torah of Moses [SOURCE:

[SOURCE: - https://youtu.be/YcqbDFYhWT8?si=1PUiDsGQeX8SxB2CRabbi Yaron Reuven says - Rabbi Yaron Reuven says that according to the Rambam a person goes to Gehinnom for doing a a righteous deed if he does not acknowledge that he is doing it because G-D told him to do it - and I assume that this should include the acknowledgement that G-D is the G-D of Torah revealed to Moses on Mt Sinai as Maimonides wrote in the Law of Kings ch. 8.11.] In

In light of these, why would G-D create groups like Australian aborgines in periods of history when they had no chance of learning about the Torah? By doing, so was notwasn't G-D condemning them to Gehinnom without a test [as the culture and time period made access to the Torah a near impossibility], given that non Jews cannot reincarnate according to a question I read here [whichhere (which cites a text called Minchas Yehuda by Rabbi Yehuda Hachayat -

Do gentiles have Gilgul Neshamot? ] So... So we cannot say that such individuals are reincarnations of those that rejected the Torah, making their Teshuva difficult or impossible as a punishment. This)?

This would imply that certain non Jews were/are born in societies where knowing that righteousness for them consists of doing the seven commandments of Noah while knowing that G-D commanded them through the Torah of Moses is near impossible, and therefore Gehinnom for such individuals is guaranteed as they would follow their natural inclination to do good without knowing about the Torah.

This is seemingly against the infinite justice of G-D, and as for the reasoning that the nations are punished like that for the sin of having rejected or deviated from the Torah is that not punishing the descendants of the ones that rejected or introduced deviation, essentially against Rabbi Tovia Singer's claimRabbi Tovia Singer's claim that the innocent are not punished for the sins of the wicked? - https://youtu.be/E5feCPllF-E?si=aae4UaELcRP47bcg

Why did G-D allow non Jews to be born in circumstances whereby they might never heard about the Torah

According to Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef, non Jews cannot do complete Teshuva, instead their Teshuva only prevents negative judgement against them in this world [SOURCE:

https://halachayomit.co.il/he/Default.aspx?HalachaID=645&PageIndex=18 ]

Furthermore, non Jews get punished for doing what they think is right without acknowledging the G-D of Israel and the Torah of Moses [SOURCE:

https://youtu.be/YcqbDFYhWT8?si=1PUiDsGQeX8SxB2C - Rabbi Yaron Reuven says that according to the Rambam a person goes to Gehinnom for doing a a righteous deed if he does not acknowledge that he is doing it because G-D told him to do it - and I assume that this should include the acknowledgement that G-D is the G-D of Torah revealed to Moses on Mt Sinai as Maimonides wrote in the Law of Kings ch. 8.11.] In light of these, why would G-D create groups like Australian aborgines in periods of history when they had no chance of learning about the Torah? By doing so was not G-D condemning them to Gehinnom without a test [as the culture and time period made access to the Torah a near impossibility], given that non Jews cannot reincarnate according to a question I read here [which cites a text called Minchas Yehuda by Rabbi Yehuda Hachayat -

Do gentiles have Gilgul Neshamot? ] So we cannot say that such individuals are reincarnations of those that rejected the Torah, making their Teshuva difficult or impossible as a punishment. This would imply that certain non Jews were/are born in societies where knowing that righteousness for them consists of doing the seven commandments of Noah while knowing that G-D commanded them through the Torah of Moses is near impossible, and therefore Gehinnom for such individuals is guaranteed as they would follow their natural inclination to do good without knowing about the Torah.

This is seemingly against the infinite justice of G-D, and as for the reasoning that the nations are punished like that for the sin of having rejected or deviated from the Torah is that not punishing the descendants of the ones that rejected or introduced deviation, essentially against Rabbi Tovia Singer's claim that the innocent are not punished for the sins of the wicked? - https://youtu.be/E5feCPllF-E?si=aae4UaELcRP47bcg

Why did G-D allow non Jews to be born in circumstances whereby they might never have heard about the Torah

According to Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef, non Jews cannot do complete Teshuva, instead their Teshuva only prevents negative judgement against them in

Furthermore, non Jews get punished for doing what they think is right without acknowledging the G-D of Israel and the Torah of Moses

[SOURCE: - Rabbi Yaron Reuven says that according to the Rambam a person goes to Gehinnom for doing a a righteous deed if he does not acknowledge that he is doing it because G-D told him to do it - and I assume that this should include the acknowledgement that G-D is the G-D of Torah revealed to Moses on Mt Sinai as Maimonides wrote in the Law of Kings ch. 8.11.]

In light of these, why would G-D create groups like Australian aborgines in periods of history when they had no chance of learning about the Torah? By doing, so wasn't G-D condemning them to Gehinnom without a test [as the culture and time period made access to the Torah a near impossibility], given that non Jews cannot reincarnate according to a question I read here (which cites a text called Minchas Yehuda by Rabbi Yehuda Hachayat... So we cannot say that such individuals are reincarnations of those that rejected the Torah, making their Teshuva difficult or impossible as a punishment)?

This would imply that certain non Jews were/are born in societies where knowing that righteousness for them consists of doing the seven commandments of Noah while knowing that G-D commanded them through the Torah of Moses is near impossible, and therefore Gehinnom for such individuals is guaranteed as they would follow their natural inclination to do good without knowing about the Torah.

This is seemingly against the infinite justice of G-D, and as for the reasoning that the nations are punished like that for the sin of having rejected or deviated from the Torah is that not punishing the descendants of the ones that rejected or introduced deviation, essentially against Rabbi Tovia Singer's claim that the innocent are not punished for the sins of the wicked?

added 1343 characters in body
Source Link

IfAccording to Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef, non Jews cannot do complete Teshuva as held by Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef, instead their Teshuva only prevents negative judgement against them in this world [SOURCE:

https://halachayomit.co.il/he/Default.aspx?HalachaID=645&PageIndex=18 and they ]

Furthermore, non Jews get punished for doing what they think is right without acknowledging the G-D of Israel and the Torah of Moses as held by Rabbi Yaron Reuven [SOURCE:

https://youtu.be/YcqbDFYhWT8?si=1PUiDsGQeX8SxB2C - Rabbi Yaron Reuven says that according to the Rambam a person goes to Gehinnom for doing a a righteous deed if he does not acknowledge that he is doing it because G-D told him to do it - and I assume that this should include the acknowledgement that G-D is the G-D of Torah revealed to Moses on Mt Sinai as Maimonides wrote in the Law of Kings ch. 8.11.] Why didIn light of these, why would G-D create groups like Australian aborgines in periods of history when they had no chance of learning about the Torah? By doing so was not G-D condemning them to Gehinnom without a test [as the culture and time period made access to the Torah a near impossibility], given that non Jews cannot reincarnate according to an answera question I read here [which cites a text called Minchas Yehuda by Rabbi Yehuda Hachayat -

Do gentiles have Gilgul Neshamot? ] So we cannot say that such individuals are reincarnations of those that rejected the Torah, making their Teshuva difficult or impossible as a punishment. Is this not This would imply that certain non Jews were/are born in societies where knowing that righteousness for them consists of doing the seven commandments of Noah while knowing that G-D commanded them through the Torah of Moses is near impossible, and therefore Gehinnom for such individuals is guaranteed as they would follow their natural inclination to do good without knowing about the Torah.

This is seemingly against the infinite justice of G-D, and as for the reasoning that the nations are punished like that for the sin of having rejected or deviated from the Torah is that not punishing the descendants of the ones that rejected or introduced deviation, essentially against Rabbi Tovia Singer's claim that the innocent are not punished for the sins of the wicked? - https://youtu.be/E5feCPllF-E?si=aae4UaELcRP47bcg

If non Jews cannot do complete Teshuva as held by Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef https://halachayomit.co.il/he/Default.aspx?HalachaID=645&PageIndex=18 and they get punished for doing what they think is right without acknowledging the G-D of Israel and the Torah of Moses as held by Rabbi Yaron Reuven https://youtu.be/YcqbDFYhWT8?si=1PUiDsGQeX8SxB2C Why did G-D create groups like Australian aborgines in periods of history when they had no chance of learning about the Torah? By doing so was not G-D condemning them to Gehinnom without a test, given that non Jews cannot reincarnate according to an answer I read here. Is this not seemingly against the infinite justice of G-D, and as for the reasoning that the nations are punished like that for the sin of having rejected the Torah is that not punishing the descendants of the ones that rejected, essentially against Rabbi Tovia Singer's claim that the innocent are not punished for the sins of the wicked?

According to Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef, non Jews cannot do complete Teshuva, instead their Teshuva only prevents negative judgement against them in this world [SOURCE:

https://halachayomit.co.il/he/Default.aspx?HalachaID=645&PageIndex=18 ]

Furthermore, non Jews get punished for doing what they think is right without acknowledging the G-D of Israel and the Torah of Moses [SOURCE:

https://youtu.be/YcqbDFYhWT8?si=1PUiDsGQeX8SxB2C - Rabbi Yaron Reuven says that according to the Rambam a person goes to Gehinnom for doing a a righteous deed if he does not acknowledge that he is doing it because G-D told him to do it - and I assume that this should include the acknowledgement that G-D is the G-D of Torah revealed to Moses on Mt Sinai as Maimonides wrote in the Law of Kings ch. 8.11.] In light of these, why would G-D create groups like Australian aborgines in periods of history when they had no chance of learning about the Torah? By doing so was not G-D condemning them to Gehinnom without a test [as the culture and time period made access to the Torah a near impossibility], given that non Jews cannot reincarnate according to a question I read here [which cites a text called Minchas Yehuda by Rabbi Yehuda Hachayat -

Do gentiles have Gilgul Neshamot? ] So we cannot say that such individuals are reincarnations of those that rejected the Torah, making their Teshuva difficult or impossible as a punishment. This would imply that certain non Jews were/are born in societies where knowing that righteousness for them consists of doing the seven commandments of Noah while knowing that G-D commanded them through the Torah of Moses is near impossible, and therefore Gehinnom for such individuals is guaranteed as they would follow their natural inclination to do good without knowing about the Torah.

This is seemingly against the infinite justice of G-D, and as for the reasoning that the nations are punished like that for the sin of having rejected or deviated from the Torah is that not punishing the descendants of the ones that rejected or introduced deviation, essentially against Rabbi Tovia Singer's claim that the innocent are not punished for the sins of the wicked? - https://youtu.be/E5feCPllF-E?si=aae4UaELcRP47bcg

Why did G-D allow non Jews to be born in circumstances whereby they might never heard about the Torah

If non Jews cannot do complete Teshuva as held by Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef https://halachayomit.co.il/he/Default.aspx?HalachaID=645&PageIndex=18 and they get punished for doing what they think is right without acknowledging the G-D of Israel and the Torah of Moses as held by Rabbi Yaron Reuven https://youtu.be/YcqbDFYhWT8?si=1PUiDsGQeX8SxB2C Why did G-D create groups like Australian aborgines in periods of history when they had no chance of learning about the Torah? By doing so was not G-D condemning them to Gehinnom without a test, given that non Jews cannot reincarnate according to an answer I read here. Is this not seemingly against the infinite justice of G-D, and as for the reasoning that the nations are punished like that for the sin of having rejected the Torah is that not punishing the descendants of the ones that rejected, essentially against Rabbi Tovia Singer's claim that the innocent are not punished for the sins of the wicked?