Questions tagged [army-military-war]
Questions about armed conflict and armed services.
207
questions
-4
votes
0
answers
37
views
Condemning Terrorism without being Islamophobic [closed]
Over the last almost year of the Gaza War, I've seen a lot of Jews not only condemning Hamas and their supporters, but also sadly crossing the line into full-blown Islamophobia, saying things like &...
0
votes
1
answer
107
views
Are soldiers sinning when they kill enemy in a war? [closed]
Soldiers are like slaves to their commanders and have to do whatever they are told to do. If not, in war war-like situation, they can be punished by their commanders. So will the soldiers be ...
- 99
1
vote
1
answer
74
views
"Of every tribe a thousand" - serving G-d being of one heart
In parshas Matos (Bamidbar 31:3-4), we read:
"And Moshe spoke to the people, saying, Arm from yourselves men for the army, and let them go against Midyan and avenge the L-rd on Midyan. Of every ...
- 11.2k
2
votes
0
answers
43
views
Why were the broken Luchos not in the Aron that was in the Kodesh Hakodoshim
in Bamidbar 10:33 the Pasuk says:
וַיִּסְעוּ֙ מֵהַ֣ר יְהֹוָ֔ה דֶּ֖רֶךְ שְׁלֹ֣שֶׁת יָמִ֑ים וַאֲר֨וֹן בְּרִית־יְהֹוָ֜ה נֹסֵ֣עַ לִפְנֵיהֶ֗ם דֶּ֚רֶךְ שְׁלֹ֣שֶׁת יָמִ֔ים לָת֥וּר לָהֶ֖ם מְנוּחָֽה׃
They ...
- 3,708
3
votes
0
answers
97
views
Torah study vs armed defense
The Midrash tells us that only Torah study protects the Jews:
Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi sent Rabbi Assi and Rabbi Ammi on a mission to organize religious education in the cities of the Land of Israel. ...
- 23k
0
votes
0
answers
25
views
Getting Divine guidance for monumental decisions
When faced with monumental, potentially world history altering decisions like going to war, it would seem appropriate to get Divine approval, like was done using Urim V'Tumim, as opposed to only ...
- 2,326
0
votes
2
answers
144
views
War for economic reasons
In Brachot 3b David gives his ministers the advice to go to war to bring Parnassah. Then they asked the Urim and Thumim. Is waging war for economic reasons halahically justified?
3
votes
1
answer
57
views
Are men with dead or divorced wives before the first year still exempt
According to Deuteronomy 24:5 a man is exempt from public service for a year when he marries a wife. What does Halacha say in the case a man marries a woman and divorced her or she dies before that ...
- 4,602
2
votes
1
answer
66
views
Is there a specific subset of Halacha which validates the need of Jewish soldiers to be selfless with their lives?
Judaism separates itself from the other Abrahamic faiths in that we are extremely serious about preserving life. In other faiths, martyrdom isn't something which just occurs due to circumstance but is ...
- 1,373
1
vote
0
answers
75
views
When can you cut down fruit trees?
The Torah enjoins us not to destroy fruit trees when you besiege a city. [Deut. 20:19-20] This grew into the Talmudic principle of בל תשחית -- Do not destroy [e.g., Shabbat 105b], based on the logic ...
- 23k
0
votes
1
answer
338
views
Is Pilegesh B''Givah a Proof that the IDF Should Widely Disseminate (with the appropriate rating) "Bearing Witness"?
The IDF created a 47-minute film based on raw footage of the evil and brutal 2023 Hamas massacre - Bearing Witness. Reports indicate that it is one of the most graphic and gruesome films ever made.
My ...
- 984
1
vote
1
answer
89
views
Do the laws of pidyon shvuyim apply as usual during a war or are they secondary to warfare considerations?
Rambam states that there is no Mitzva as great as Pidyon Shvuyim. (משנה תורה, הלכות מתנות עניים
ח׳) He sets forth there that its greatness is based on the fact that the prisoner is in constant lack of ...
- 16.1k
0
votes
0
answers
34
views
Why did Yonatan start up with the Plishtim?
In 1 Shmuel 13 Yonatan seemingly unprovoked, attacks the Plishtim triggering a war. The text does not indicate that Yonatan was told to do this by Shaul, Shmuel or Hashem. Further on in the chapter we ...
- 14.7k
2
votes
1
answer
126
views
Legalities of launching a preemptive strike on shabbat
Should the IDF be allowed to launch an offensive on Shabbat if it seems as if there will be no threat from any opposing forces until Shabbat is over?
- 23
5
votes
1
answer
254
views
Punishments for a soldier who kills another soldier in unintentional friendly fire
An IDF Soldier is returning to base, and a sniper on guard sees the IDF soldier. He sees the IDF soldier he thinks the person is Hamas. He then shoots the IDF Soldier in defense of the base.
Under ...
- 53
2
votes
1
answer
188
views
How did the Jews have weapons before they vanquished the Plishtim?
According to 1 Shmuel ch. 13 the Jews did not have weapons with which to fight the Plishtim yet in a previous battle in chapter 11 the Jewish army defeated the Ammonites, which would seemingly have ...
- 14.7k
3
votes
0
answers
41
views
Burying/saving body parts of people who are still alive [duplicate]
Unfortunately, post 7 October 2023, I have seen the scenario a number of times. If a person has a part of their body removed (e.g., during a battle) does that body part need to be immediately buried? ...
- 10.5k
1
vote
1
answer
310
views
Does a Jewish army require permission from Gedolim to wage war
Basically, as the title says, in the modern era without Sanhedrin, does a Jewish army require permission from the rabbonim of the times to wage war?
If they do, would the current conflict in Israel be ...
- 13
0
votes
0
answers
54
views
Is there any opinion suggesting Jews returning from warfare should cleanse themselves in the mikvah to purify from combat?
We are taught that because King David had spilled the blood of the Canaanites in his conquest of Haaretz Yisrael, he was forbidden from building the Beit Hamikdash. This responsibility fell unto ...
- 1,373
1
vote
3
answers
246
views
Does every bullet have a name on it (during war)?
R Avraham ibn Ezra writes (Devarim 20:7) that folks (can) die in wars even if it isn't yet their time to go:
ולא לקחה – בנשואין. והנה זה הכתוב לאות
על כי יש מי שימות בבוא יומו, רק המת במלחמה מת בלא ...
- 3,220
0
votes
1
answer
55
views
War after the miracle of oil?
One popular explanation for the name Chanukah is that on 25th of Kislev (כ"ה) they had a respite of their enemies (חנו מאויביהם). (Actually I am not so sure about the first source of this either. ...
- 1,201
4
votes
2
answers
953
views
Is taking an Eshet Yefat To'ar allowed today?
The Torah provides that a Jewish soldier may, by following a specific process, take a woman captive as his wife and convert her to Judaism as an אשת יפת תואר (Devarim 21:10-14).
Is this provision ...
- 1,418
3
votes
2
answers
535
views
New responsa on releasing terrorists in exchange for hostages?
The State of Israel has over the years engaged in the exchange of terrorists and criminals in exchange for the release of hostages. This topic has prior been explored in posts such as Q 10731 and Q ...
- 9,320
4
votes
1
answer
137
views
Milchemes mitzvah in Shoftim according to Rambam
According to the Rambam that you need a Melech for a milchemes mitzvah, how does the Rambam understand all the milchamos in the book of Shoftim?
- 273
0
votes
0
answers
53
views
Confused about the layout of this
Joshua 6:12-13 Speaks about the Kohanim, armed men, and rear guard and how they were ordered when they walked with the Aron. Is there a representation of this actually looked, I'm not sure who was in ...
- 43
0
votes
0
answers
39
views
Is an enemy counteroffensive in an optional war a milchemet mitzva?
After consulting the Urim vThumin, Shlomo decides to conquer Egypt. He captures the Nile Delta.
An Egyptian force from the south moves upward to liberate it. Since the Jews are now on the defensive, ...
- 8,653
5
votes
2
answers
340
views
Is the war to protect the State of Israel from attacks from terrrorists a Milchemes Mitzvah
The Rambam in Melachim 5:1 says that one of the cases of Milchemes Mitzvah is coming to the aid of Jews being attacked by an enemy.
Does that mean that the war in Gaza (declared on 07/10/2023) is a ...
- 6,043
2
votes
0
answers
103
views
If a Jew is conscripted into a non-Jewish army
What are the halachot for conscription in say USA. If a religious Jew is conscripted, to fight to defend Israel, for example, should he consider himself part of the milchement mitzva? Should he keep ...
- 12.6k
2
votes
1
answer
234
views
Rabbi Grossman's tzedakkah segula for soldiers
In Israeli Dati social media circles there's been a little bit of a buzz recently1 over a segula apparently first introduced by Rabbi Grossman during the Second Lebanon War (see here from 0:52). The ...
- 26.8k
1
vote
0
answers
149
views
Would the dispensation of Yefat Toar apply to homosexual men?
My understanding is that one of the reasons for the permissibility of a man to sleep with a woman who is part of an enemy nation during war is because the Torah is "speaking against the man's ...
- 14.7k
1
vote
0
answers
81
views
Ethics of working in defense
The following is not halacha l'maaseh.
Say I am currently looking for a new role. In my search, I come across a fair number of (US-based) defense contractors that seem to have openings for what I am ...
- 11
4
votes
0
answers
148
views
Meaning of a Talmud statement about acceptable casualties of war
The Talmud says:
Shmuel... said: A government that allows one-sixth to die [by going to war] is not punished. [Shevuot 35b]
I don't understand what this means. That a ruler is allowed to risk the ...
- 23k
3
votes
4
answers
391
views
Prevention of Lashon Hara as a protection for military wars
In light of the current situation in Israel, one of the calls that has been made is specifically to try and cut down on Lashon Hara.
I have seen two similar sources concerning the generation of Achav:
...
- 33.9k
2
votes
3
answers
305
views
What does Halacha say about human shields
What is the Torah approach to when terrorists are using civilians as human shields? Are you allowed to bomb the building?
- 273
14
votes
3
answers
1k
views
What should one do to help Israel during war?
Regarding this terrible attack and subsequent war on October 2023, how would our Sages say we can help Israel during a war like this? I’m not just looking for answers like “pray”, but rather maybe ...
- 3,095
0
votes
2
answers
446
views
Why was Avshalom riding a donkey into battle?
In the battle between Avshalom's army and David's forces Avshalom is riding a donkey which runs away when Avshalom is caught by his hair in a tree.
וַיִּקָּרֵא אַבְשָׁלוֹם לִפְנֵי עַבְדֵי דָוִד ...
- 14.7k
1
vote
1
answer
62
views
Is Chushai to blame for the deaths in Avshalom's rebellion?
In 2 Shmuel 17 Ahitophel counsels Avshalom to immediately pursue David with 12,000 soldiers and predicts that they will be able to kill David without having to kill David's men.
At David's behest, ...
- 14.7k
1
vote
0
answers
96
views
Do non-Israelite soldiers in the army of an Israelite king observe Shabbat?
Does וְגֵרְךָ, אֲשֶׁר בִּשְׁעָרֶיךָ apply to non-Israelite soldiers serving in the army of an Israelite king?
- 2,697
2
votes
0
answers
176
views
Yefas Toar - rape allowed by the Torah before the marriage?
Ki Saitzai deals with the Eishes Yefas Toar “woman of beautiful form” taken in battle.
Ramban and Rabbeinu Tam say that the Torah permits the soldier to have relations with the maiden immediately. ...
- 48.4k
3
votes
1
answer
122
views
what is the difference between שלל, ביזה, and חרם?
We know that there are no true synonyms in the Torah. What does each of these connote? (to pass the test here - i googled and did not find anything)
- 383
0
votes
0
answers
51
views
Did all the midyanim die? [duplicate]
In the war with Midyon, the Torah infers all of their men were killed, and girls not of mature age were spared
Now if they were all killed, how do they appear in Shoftim as being the oppressors of ...
- 464
0
votes
1
answer
71
views
Is profiting off of a war allowed in Judaism? Like for example, is it allowed in Judaism to sell equipment to both sides?
Historically, Jews often lived in regions where it wasn't uncommon for a war to occur. I imagine some shrewd businessmen took advantage of this to profit by doing things like selling equipment or ...
- 1,018
0
votes
0
answers
64
views
Malbim on the irrationality/illegitimacy of Amalek
Malbim on Shmuel 1:15:2 writes about the irrationality, or perhaps the illegitimacy of Amalek's war with Bnei Yisrael:
"כה אמר ה' צבאות, הנה התורה בארה בטעם מצות מיחוי זכר עמלק כמה טעמים כמ&...
- 26.8k
1
vote
0
answers
76
views
What’s the Jewish equivalent to The Art of War?
I know from Parashas Vayishlach, there is a reference to how a Jew should prepare for war. Yaakov prays and sends Esau a large gift to appease him.
Where can I find more sources on how a Jew fights a ...
- 21
1
vote
0
answers
27
views
What changed in the later First Temple period that increased interaction with further kingdoms?
If you read the Book of Kings, the nations with which Israel (or later, Judah and Israel) was always either warring or allying themselves are basically its neighbors: Egypt, Lebanon ("Tyre"),...
- 135k
2
votes
5
answers
1k
views
Why didn't Moses fight Amalek himself?
"וַיָּבֹא עֲמָלֵק וַיִּלָּחֶם עִם־יִשְׂרָאֵל בִּרְפִידִם׃, וַיֹּאמֶר מֹשֶׁה אֶל־יְהוֹשֻׁעַ בְּחַר־לָנוּ אֲנָשִׁים וְצֵא הִלָּחֵם בַּעֲמָלֵק מָחָר אָנֹכִי נִצָּב עַל־רֹאשׁ הַגִּבְעָה וּמַטֵּה ...
- 27.2k
4
votes
1
answer
233
views
Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett's trip to Moscow on Shabbat to meet Putin
I am an Italian ben Noach.
We have all seen that Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett went to Moscow on Shabbat to meet Putin.
I believe that, since this trip has been functional to find a solution ...
- 2,646
2
votes
0
answers
24
views
Devarim 20: division of roles
Devarim 20:1-9 is a list of instructions that must be given orally to soldiers before setting out to battle. Rashi (on verse 8) explains that a priest says the words in verses 3-4, and that they also ...
- 2,568
3
votes
2
answers
455
views
How should one understand the reference to ‘horsemen’, ‘bows’ and ‘arrows’ in the Gog / Magog prophecies?
Shalom.
I am a bit confused by the reference of ‘horses’ and ‘horsemen’, ‘bows’ and ‘arrows’ in Yechezkel 38 and 39. It certainly would be a greater miracle than the one described if mankind were ...
- 1,490
1
vote
0
answers
56
views
Death on the battlefield
Last Shabbat, I was reading a book called היהודים בערב (The Jews in Arabia) by Dr. Yisrael Ben Ze'ev. In the book, a section was dedicated to a pre-Islamic Arabian Jewish poet named Shmuel ben Adiyah. ...
- 26.8k