2

sometimes when browsing youtube for interesting videos, it is inevitable to sometimes encounter some lewd pictures.

would this make it forbidden to browse sites like youtube according to halacha?

the question is not about general internet use but about using (without necessity) sites with high liability of bumping into lewd pictures like youtube or the like.

please source.

  • 6
    Same with walking outside in the summer – Double AA Feb 22 at 12:58
  • 1
    If you think that matters it should be in your question.... – Double AA Feb 22 at 13:13
  • 1
    Who said no choice? Surely you need your Rabbi's permission to watch Youtube just as you need one to go outside in the summer. – Al Berko Feb 22 at 13:27
  • 2
    Depends who you ask, there are communities where Internet is forbidden, some where it is allowed only for work, some only with filters, some where everyone does what they want. I am afraid this question is very opinion-based, different people will have different opinions, all "correct" – mbloch Feb 22 at 13:41
  • 1
    @mbloch asking about youtube or the like – michael Feb 22 at 13:50
2

I had a talk on this topic with R' Chaim Weiss in Jerusalem. He told me that Shmirat Eynayim is not different from putting air-bags in your car - both serve to protect you from overriding serious prohibitions.

As those examples are preventive measures, not transgressions by themselves, one should contact a Rabbi on his personal considerations: strengths, weaknesses, benefits or losses, just as one has to consult a Rabbi on all other dangers - air/water pollution, smoking, using public transportation (rush hours), going out on vacation etc.

As a computer guy, I'm asked all the time to install a proper internet filter for my Haredi clients. And I always tell them that I'm not a Posek and they need to consult their own Rebbe to pick a suitable filter for them, like Rimon, Nativ, Etrog, Netfree etc. Same is true for the Kosher phones bonanza, where every Haredi Beis Din (in Israel at least) has its own filtering company (do they also report to the Rebbis?).

  • 1
    thanks but not asking about general internet use. see edit – michael Feb 22 at 14:08
1

Not quite sure about the source (it was one of the many articles you encounter on chabad.org, would take a while to find that one but if you're interested I might take the search) but it's pretty much the same with vile thoughts (and oh boy, do I have lots of them):

'It's one thing if a bird flies over your head. It's an entire other thing if the bird nests on your head' (a quote from said article).

Same applies to those stupid youtube videos where some people decide to whore themselves out a bit to grab some attention (in form of views one might say) with these primitive thumbnails and titles. Indeed, it is inevitable to come across one of the aforementioned toxic thumbnails in the 'recommended' tab. But if you just see it blurry and quickly, without focusing on it and scrolling right past that garbage, it will be alright. Just as Double AA said in the comments, walking outside in summer is pretty much the same. You might see it from your peripheral vision: don't turn your head in that case. It's pointless, I think. Especially if you're married.

Recognize the 'threats' early on and don't pay attention to them after you understood what it is about.

Again, if you insist on the source (chabad.org article) I'll do the search. But bear in mind it's a rav who wrote it. Don't know if that suits you or if you exclusively accept talmudic/halacha sources.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .