1

This question already has an answer here:

Rashi at the beginning of Vayechi (Bereishis 47:28) asks:

לָמָּה פָּרָשָׁה זוֹ סְתוּמָה

Why is this Parsha “closed”?

As Sifsei Chachamim ad. loc. explains:

למה פרשה זו סתומה כו'. כלומר קבלה הוא בידינו מעזרא ע"ה שפרשת ויחי הוא תחלת פסקא ולא חדא פרשה היא עם וישב ישראל וכו' ודרך פרשה סתומה שיעורה ט' אותיות והכא כולה סתומה ואין בה ריוח כלל:

That is to say: There is a tradition in our hands from Ezra, peace be upon him, that Parshas Vayechi is the beginning of a passage, and it is not one parsha with “and Yisrael dwelled” [i.e. the end of Vayigash, whose final passuk begins with that]. The way of a closed parshah is [to have a gap] measuring 9 letters, but here it’s entirely closed, and there is no gap at all.

Is there a problem with beginning a Sidra in the middle of a Parsha, and that’s why the question is asked here? Or is there really no problem with beginning a Sidra in the middle of a Parsha, and the question is merely why the custom is that only at Vayechi do we do so? Or, a third option, even at Vayechi we don’t begin in the middle of a Parsha; Rashi’s wording of “Parsha” implies that the tradition is that this is a new Parsha, just like any other place where there actually is a gap.

Which understanding of the question is correct?

marked as duplicate by DonielF, Community Feb 17 at 20:17

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • 1
    Related: judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/66451/… – Alex Feb 17 at 19:34
  • I understood the SC as saying your third option. I pointed out in a comment somewhere else on this site that a nafka mina is if you can end an aliya within 3 pesukim of this point (if your reading has weird boundaries for some reason, like a hurricane on Shabbos Vayigash). – Heshy Feb 17 at 19:36
  • The reading for fast days begins in the middle of a parsha. – Alex Feb 17 at 19:38

Browse other questions tagged .