The chapter starts out saying that the anger of the Lord was kindled against Israel. (Does this just mean the northern kingdom?) Here Rashi says he doesn't know what it is about:


Then David is told to count the Jews, but then it is revealed that this is a great sin, and there is a plague on the people for doing exactly this.

In the book of Chronicles the same exact episode is described but not as God doing it. The first verse in the book of Samuel attributes it to God moving David to do it, which Rashi says "provoked".

What is going on? The first verse in the book of Samuel attributes it to God, which is very weird!

  • 2
    Regarding your first statement, it cannot mean "just the northern kingdom", as Judah and Israel didn't split until much after David. – ezra Apr 29 '18 at 18:40
  • Well, since the book of Samuel was written with prophesy so the prophet-author knew what Gcd was doing. Chronicles was written with divine inspiration (Ruach Hakodesh) - a lesser level where one is not privy to Gcd's direct input. – Danny Schoemann May 1 '18 at 13:58

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .