Is there a special name for a congregant who follows the Torah text in the actual scroll with a yad at the bimah while someone stands next to him/her and chants the text from a chumash (when there is no trained Torah reader available who can chant directly from the Torah scroll). That congregant doesn't need to be an oleh and get an aliyah (although they can), their job is to follow the text carefully with a yad while another congregant chants it out loud from a chumash. I'm just wondering if there is a special term describing this job.

I saw this situation at a service where there was a minyan but no one knew how to chant the Torah from the scroll. So one person used a chumash instead to chant the text out loud but another congregant quietly followed the text with a yad in the actual scroll. They tried to make up for the fact that no one was able to chant it from the scroll - the text was sung out loud from the chumash and at the same time quietly traced with a yad in the Torah scroll.

  • 3
    Is this person repeating the reading from inside the Torah scroll? Otherwise I don't understand what they are doing up there
    – Double AA
    Dec 9 '17 at 22:38
  • 2
    Generally, there wouldn't be a title for something that has no halachic or minhag precedence. What you described seems to fit that group. Congregational Torah reading must be done from a kosher Torah scroll. Otherwise, there is no mitzvah being accomplished other than that of studying Torah which does not require a congregation and can be done individually. Seems that you've essentially described a chevruta.
    – DanF
    Dec 10 '17 at 2:51
  • 2
    I have seen a case where there was not a minyan on Shabbat where they took out the Torah scroll and covered it, and read from a Chumash instead. The mitzvah of public reading was not accomplished, but you might say a "lesser" mitzvah of Torah study was still done. The situation Rebekah describes seems similar.
    – Mike
    Dec 10 '17 at 3:06
  • 1
  • 1
    It sounds like you did it backwards. I'll see if I can locate the halachic source in O.C. I believe he says that in such situations, the person should read from the Chumash quietly and the "main" person should read loudly from the Torah scroll. The point is that the mitzvah of congregational reading is accomplished specifically when read from a scroll. Of course, I can't post an answer until this question is reopened.
    – DanF
    Dec 12 '17 at 15:32

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .