5

What is the status of books from rabbis who were accused of impropriety? The question would also likely also apply to online shiurim.

For example, here is is a very good book from a rav who admitted to voyeurism in his shul's mikve, lost his job in the process and was convicted of prison.

Can one study the book? If not can one even keep it?

6
6

R. Schachter says: "They should not be used. Since his sefarim include his ideas and rulings, they fit into the prohibition against studying Torah from someone who is unfit due to his improper behavior."

https://jewishaction.com/religion/jewish-law/halachah-and-the-fallen-rabbi-q-a-with-rabbi-hershel-schachter/

5

Rambam (MT, Torah study, beg. Ch. 4) states:

וְכֵן הָרַב שֶׁאֵינוֹ הוֹלֵךְ בְּדֶרֶךְ טוֹבָה אַף עַל פִּי שֶׁחָכָם גָּדוֹל הוּא וְכָל הָעָם צְרִיכִין לוֹ אֵין מִתְלַמְּדִין מִמֶּנּוּ עַד שׁוּבוֹ לַמּוּטָב. שֶׁנֶּאֱמַר (מלאכי ב ז) "כִּי שִׂפְתֵי כֹהֵן יִשְׁמְרוּ דַעַת וְתוֹרָה יְבַקְשׁוּ מִפִּיהוּ כִּי מַלְאַךְ ה' צְבָאוֹת הוּא". אָמְרוּ חֲכָמִים אִם הָרַב דּוֹמֶה לְמַלְאַךְ ה' צְבָאוֹת תּוֹרָה יְבַקְּשׁוּ מִפִּיהוּ אִם לָאו אַל יְבַקְּשׁוּ תּוֹרָה מִפִּיהוּ

Trans. (Sefaria):

Likewise, a Rabbi who does not follow the good way, though he be a great scholar and all of the people stand in need of him no instruction should be received from him until his return to goodness, as it is said: "For the priests' lips should keep knowledge and they should seek the Law at his mouth; for he is the messenger of the Lord of Hosts" (Mal. 2.7). Thereupon the sages said: "If the Rabbi be like unto the messenger of the Lord of Hosts then shall they seek the Law at his mouth, if not, they shall not seek the Law at his mouth.

However, R. Yirmiyahu Lew in his commentary to Rambam, Divrei Yirmiahu (loc. cit.) brings his father's opinion that learning from such a teacher's books would be permitted as one is able to "take the good and leave the bad", as we see from Rambam himself who studies books of deplorable people.

13
  • So I can take the good and leave the bad in the works of Shabsai Tzvi? Or the New Testament, chas veshalom?
    – ezra
    Nov 10 '17 at 15:11
  • 3
    @ezra According to the DY - yep. (Btw, why "heaven forbid"? There were distinguished rabbis who -I'm certain- read (parts/all?) of the NT. Don't recall off-hand but I've seen them quote it; R. Elazar Horowitz comes to mind.)
    – Oliver
    Nov 10 '17 at 15:17
  • 2
    @ezra How about Rambam himself who states that he learned all the works of the ancient idolaters he could get his hands on.
    – mevaqesh
    Nov 10 '17 at 19:59
  • @Oliver R. Elazar Horowitz, although he was an Orthodox Jew, was controversial in his day and would occasionally daven in a Reform temple!
    – ezra
    Nov 11 '17 at 23:57
  • @mevaqesh - And your average Jew is on the same tremendous faith level as the Ramban, to where he would not be misled by the heresy contained within a book?
    – ezra
    Nov 11 '17 at 23:58

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .