5

A famous Medrash appears in slightly different versions in Lev Rabbah 32:05 and Songs Rabbah 4:12. The Medrah praises the Jews of the Egyptian slavery for certain attributes, such as their retention of their Hebrew names. It goes on to list several examples of Hebrew names retained (Reuvein, Shimon, Yehudah, Yoseif, Binyomin) and other foreign names (Alexandri, Leon, Lestes, Luliani, Rofeh or Rufus) for which they were not exchanged. The Hebrew and foreign names were paired inconsistently in the Hebrew and Soncino volumes that I saw. In the Hebrew Lev Rabbah, a commentary called something like Chidushei Haradal attempts to sort it all out.

Now on the one hand, it makes no difference which Hebrew name is paired with which foreign name in the example; the point is not that any particular foreign name was avoided, but that all foreign names were avoided, as Hebrew names were retained. The Hebrew names in the example are some of the sons of Yisro'el, and there's a long tradition of using such names as hypothetical parties (for example at Pesachim 31a1 and in Rashi's comments to Lev 1:3). Perhaps these are simply arbitrary examples.

Still, there's something funny about the examples. There's a finger-wagging tone: they didn't change their names, but what about you? Why can't you be more like your big brothers Reuvein and Shimon? Perhaps this tone derives partly from the use of classical names apparently more appropriate to the milieu of Chazal than to the period of Egyptian slavery supposedly under consideration. So I wonder: were these substitutions common in the period of Chazal, and if so, why? (It reminds me of American Jews born in the 1940's, amongst whom Morris was Moshe, and Isador was Yisro'el, and it all seemed to go without saying.) The aforementioned Chidushei Haradal speaks to the point at 21.

enter image description here On his view of it, the contrasting pairs are Yehudah/Leoni, Reuvein/Rofe and Yosieif/Adatish.

1. Reuvein/Rofe Rofe, he thinks, is a Latin nickname for Maruvein, or from Rubino, the Latin name for the color red and for the red stone known to us as Avnei Oidem [as at Ex 28:17 and Ex 39:10 to 13]... and Rufus is the Latin word for "red." I'm a little confused what that is supposed to add up to. I guess that the Chidushei Haradal thinks of Rufus and Rofe as one name, used for Reuvein purely because it sounds a bit like it; and he thinks that the connections to colors or gemstones have nothing to do with it? The Living Torah notes at Ex 28:17 that Oidem represents Reuvein on the breastplate, and that it is red; and classical sources are cited. It feels like this is what the Chidushei Haradal was thinking, but I don't see that he says it. (And by the way, English dictionaries give a Latin word like Rubinus in the etymology of Ruby.)

2. Yehudah/Leoni Leoni is the Latin word for Lion, used for Yehudah because of the passage (Gen. 49:9) in which Yisro'el calls Yehudah a lion.

3. Yoiseif/Adatish Adatish is the Latin word for Yoiseif. Now what could this mean? How is there a Latin word for Yoiseif? The names don't sound alike -- do they? Could Adatish somehow mean "gathered," apparently the meaning of the Hebrew name?

And what of the remaining names?

4. Lulianus According to Jastrow, Lulianus is a Latin nickname for Julius. Assuming that the J of Julius had a Y sound, perhaps it was perceived as similar to a Hebrew name with an initial Y, like Yehudah and Yoiseif. Those names are already paired, but perhaps one of them actually had two code words?

5. Binyomin/Alexander All the books pair Binyomin to Alexander. Wikipedia explains that the name Alexander means "Defender of the people," "Defending men" or "Protector of men."

I don't see any Hebrew name on the list with that meaning; and I don't see any that sounds like Alexander, either. Binyomin has several senses amongst the Rishoinim. My hunch is that both names were taken to mean “Southerner,” partly because of the Egyptian city Alexandria, which is south of Israel and Bavel.

enter image description here

So to restate: I'm asking for historical evidence or logical reason to suppose that Jews in the world of Chazal used particular foreign names as the translation of certain Hebrew names (whether names mentioned here or any others).

  • Would the one who cast the vote to close care to explain? – Chaim Jun 14 '17 at 13:56
  • he.wikipedia.org/wiki/… – Loewian Jun 14 '17 at 14:54
  • 4
    @mevaqesh I see what you mean... but the analysis of rabbinic writings seems to be proper to this stack exchange and only this one. You guys went nuts for the question about rabbinic references to the American slavery. Don't you think my new question is up our alley here? – Chaim Jun 14 '17 at 15:42
  • 1
    Two things: Reuvein/Rofe Rofe, he thinks, is a Latin nickname for Maruvein מראובן = than Reuven, not a different name. I think he might mean "Rufe" Could Adatish somehow mean "gathered," apparently the meaning of the Hebrew name? It's יוסף ה' לי בן אחר, not אסף אלהים את חרפתי, from this verb, though אדעטיש looks more like addetis than any other conjugation, which is an odd one to choose for a name – b a Jul 22 '18 at 17:19
  • 1
    1. When he says מראובן, the Radal means "than ראובן." From your wording it seems you interpreted "Mareuvein" as a name. I think he interprets the nickname רופא as Rufe. 2. Yes, I was saying that the Radal means to interpret יוסף as in the verse "may God add another child for me" and not "God gathered my disgrace" because אדעטיש is clearly a transcription of the Latin word for adding. (Also, I only get pinged by @ba, not @b a) – b a Jul 23 '18 at 23:09

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .