Assuming that there is a reliable eruv, are there any halachic issues with sledding on Shabbos?
-
1what with גורר ועושה חריץ בפסיק רישא – kouty Dec 18 '16 at 2:45
-
@kouty Would that apply to snow (in which it should? serve no beneficial purpose and which is destined to melt)? – Loewian Dec 18 '16 at 2:48
-
and the known pb of עובדא דחול? – kouty Dec 18 '16 at 2:51
-
1Offhand, it sounds like it may be the same questions as bike riding on Shabbat. Some communities (esp. in Israel) allow it. Most don't. I suspect the main issue is that it's considered a "weekday" type activity. Offhand, I can't think of any direct melachotthat might be violated. Is there any concern of "smoothening" (memarech?) the snow by using the sled? There's no question that the sled flattens and smoothens the snow. What about any concern that the rope to the sled may tear? – DanF Dec 18 '16 at 2:54
-
1סימן שא סעיף טז קטע בשתי רגליו ומהלך על שוקיו ועל ארכבותיו ועושה סמוכות של עור לשוקיו יוצא בהם בשבת: may be that this is a little similar so if sled is allowed, no need to eruv. but @DanF is right uvda dechol is the pb – kouty Dec 18 '16 at 3:15
|
Show 3 more comments
According to Rabbi Elchanan Lewis on yeshiva.co there is no problem in sledding on shabbos as long as there's an eruv.
-
However ,if it would be a sled used for actual travel then it would be uvdin dchol,it must be talking about a recreational sled,or children's sled – sam Jun 25 '18 at 0:45
