8

My son asked why the letters have to be black, considering there are lots of other colors out there.

3

The midrash tanchuma below brings this posuk

shir hashirim 5.11

his locks are curled, [they are as] black as a raven

Rashi black as a raven: All these are beauty for a young man

It seems that black is beautiful


It is conected with the idea of Black fire on white fire

Talmud yerushalmi shekolim.

התורה שנתן לו הקב"ה למשה נתנה לו אש לבנה חרותה באש שחורה היא אש מובללת באש חצובה מאש ונתונה מאש דכתיב (דברים לג) מימינו אש דת למו:

The Torah given to Moses was engraved with black fire upon white fire... As it is written (devorim 33.2) His right hand was a fiery Law for them.

Rashi on devorim 33.2

It was originally written before God in [letters of] black fire upon [a background of] white fire. — [Tanchuma Bereishith 1] He gave it to them on tablets, inscribed, [as it were,] by His right hand [thus it is said here, “from His right hand”].
Another explanation of אֵשׁ דָּת : As the Targum renders it, that He gave it to them from amidst the fire.

The beginning of midrash tanchuma

והתורה במה היתה כתובה? על גבי אש לבנה באש שחורה שנא' (שיר השירים,): קווצותיו תלתלים שחורות כעורב, On what was the Torah written (before the world was created)? On white fire, with black fire as it says (shir hashirim 5.11) his locks are curled, [they are as] black as a raven


The leagal reason

@doubleAA brought a source in the comments above

I am bringing it in English

Mishneh Torah »Sefer Ahavah » Tefillin, Mezuzah and Sefer Torah.
Chapter One

Halacha 1

There are ten requirements for tefillin. All of them are halachot transmitted to Moses on Mount Sinai. It is necessary to fulfill them all. Therefore, if one made any changes with regard to them, the tefillin are not fit for use: ... They must be written in ink;

Halacha 5

If so, what was excluded by the halachah conveyed to Moses on Mount Sinai, which stated that it be written in ink?

It excludes tints of other colors, such as red, green, and the like. If even one letter of a Torah scroll, tefillin, or mezuzot is in another tint or in gold, they are invalid.

Commentary to halacha 5

If so, - i.e., if there are no specific substances which are excluded, as stated above

what was excluded by the halachah conveyed to Moses on Mount Sinai, which stated that it be written in ink? It excludes tints of other colors, such as red, green -Megillah 17a explicitly disqualifies a megillah written in red ink. From that and other sources, it appears that such ink was frequently used at that time, but was deemed unacceptable for use for a Torah scroll.

and the like. - Note the Bi'ur Halachah (32), which states that even blue ink is unacceptable.

If even one letter of a Torah scroll, tefillin, or mezuzot is in another tint or in gold - Soferim 1:9 relates that a Torah scroll was written for Alexander with every one of the names of God written in gold. When the Sages heard about this, they said that the scroll should be entombed.

Besides excluding the use of gold-colored ink, the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chayim 32:3) explains that covering the ink with gold dust is not acceptable.

they are invalid. - From this, we learn that all black inks are acceptable, regardless of their makeup. Though scribes continue to make ink in the traditional fashion, there is no prohibition against using commercially produced black ink.

  • In summary: Halacha l'Moshe Misinai, maybe because of white fire black fire. – Liron Nov 21 '16 at 17:08
  • @Liron I added some more, it needs to be that way becouse of halocho moshe misinai, but the reason of the halocho is that Hashem (kviyahol) made the Torah it with black fire on white fire, and it is beautiful (I added some sources see above) – hazoriz Nov 21 '16 at 17:19
  • From the context in shir hashirim, it seems white and gold and rose and sapphire are also beautiful. – Liron Nov 21 '16 at 17:23
  • @Liron yes and probably each one is has its use, the gold, and sapphire in the Bais hamikdash, rose the thread on the horn of animal in the Bais hamikdash on yom Kippur was red and turned white (like it says that a red rose when but in fire (do teshuva) turns white) , I am sure there are more kabolistic/chasidic explanations for all of your examples (I am not a big export in these, but there are a few here) , the meddrash seems to compare/connect sposificly the black to the letters – hazoriz Nov 21 '16 at 17:42
  • 1
    "there is no prohibition against using commercially produced black ink". Do you have any idea what the halachic definition of "black" is. Commercial black inks might contain traces of other pigments that may or may not be mentioned in its ingredients. Would such traces be acceptable? – DanF Nov 21 '16 at 18:22
-2

The previous (accepted) answer, unfortunately, says nothing about the REASON for the letters to be black.

  1. [One of] the REAL explanations why, according to the Lurianic tradition is that there are two different parts of the scroll that are called "the Torah" - one is the BLACK of the letters, and the second is the WHITE of the surrounding parchment.

  2. The black part (the actual letters) is one that is read and heard, and that represents the Binah (the "feminine" part), which is the Reduction (צמצום) of the eternal light to our human understanding, as it was done on Mt Sinai (that the Torah took the form of letters).

  3. The white part is one that we (the Hassidishers tradition) look when we say "זאת התורה" as it represents the [unbound] light of the Torah that is the Chochmah (the "masculine" part).

Hence the Halachah that the letters must be black against the white background.

I know, it's a little bit of Kabbalah and hard to comprehend at first, but this proves why it cannot be the other way around in any way!

  • This doesn't really answer why the letters couldn't be any other color - just have to have contrast with the parchment. – Liron Nov 13 '18 at 14:24
  • @Liron That's too much Kabbalah in one answer. That represents Malchus which is "lack of light" which is black, that's why we wear black etc... – Al Berko Nov 13 '18 at 15:02

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .