3

Every siddur, machzor, and bentcher that I've noticed writes בְּיוֹם, with a sheva, and then divides up into different cases (חג המצות/חג השבועות/חג הסוכות/השמיני חג העצרת, with additional options in bentching).

On Shemini Atzeret, it would seem that בַּיּוֹם would make more sense. On every other Yom Tov, and on Rosh Chodesh, יום is samuch to the following words, so it doesn't get a ה' הידיעה. But on Shemini Atzeret, my understanding is that we are giving two descriptions of the day, יום השמיני and חג העצרת, and יום is not samuch. I would therefore have expected בַּיּוֹם.

I checked the Artscroll Ashkenaz machzor, and it writes בְּיוֹם even in the Shemini Atzeret shemoneh esreis, when there's no need to divide into cases.

Does anyone know of someone who says you should say בַּיּוֹם, or any siddurim or machzorim that write it this way?

If not, what does בְּיוֹם השמיני mean?

(Note that I'm asking specifically according to those who say ביום השמיני חג העצרת, but feel free to include other minhagim in addition.)

  • You mean bayom hashmini chag atseret or beyom sHmini atseret hachag haze? – kouty Oct 19 '16 at 16:57
  • @kouty Neither, similar to the first one but with an extra ה. My minhag/artscroll ashkenaz says ביום השמיני חג העצרת. My question is the nekudot of ביום. Do you have a source for bayom vs beyom as you say in the comment? Because that would be an answer. – Heshy Oct 19 '16 at 17:14
  • Adding the ה to get השמיני instead of שמיני was a change 150 years ago by R Wolf Heidenheim commons.wikimedia.org/w/… . The traditional wording is ביום שמיני חג העצרת הזה. Why he didn't think to change the previous word when it shows up in Yaaleh veYavo isn't that interesting a question to me at least. Probably he just didn't think it was needed. We have exceptions about the definite article in Tanakh, I believe. – Double AA Dec 13 '16 at 23:35

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .