I've always understand conventional Jewish belief is that there are different aspects to the soul, and each one provides different abilities. The נפש is common to all living creatures and it is the source of life. The נשמה is unique to humans, and it's what provides שכל/intelligence as well as the ability to speak (some refer to this as the רוח specifically). What that means then is before Man received the נשמה, there was no ability to speak. Sources which show this are as follows:

The beginning of Bereishis describes the creation of Adam

בראשית ב:ז

וייצר יקוק אלקים את האדם מן האדמה ויפח באפיו נשמת חיים, ויהי האדם לנפש חיה

And G-d formed man from the earth, and blew into his nostrils a נשמה of life, and man became a living being

Targum Onkelos translates the last half of the verse as

ונפח באנפוהי נשמתא דחיי והות באדם לרוח ממללא

And He blew into his nostrils a נשמה of life, and there was in man a talking spirit

Meaning, Man after receiving the נשמה became able to speak.

The Ramban on this verse comments similarly:

י...'וייצר יקוק אלקים את האדם' יצירת תנועה...ואחרי שיצרו בהרגשה, 'נפח באפיו נשמת חיים' מפי עליון, להוסיף הנפש הזאת על היצירה הנזכרת, ויהי האדם כולו לנפש חיה, כי בנשמה הזאת ישכיל וידבר

'And G-d formed man', the formation of the ability to move. And after he formed him with this ability, 'He blew into his nostrils a נשמה of life' from the mouth of the Upper One. This נפש was to increase on the formation previously mentioned. And man became entirely a living being, because with this נשמה he became intelligent and could speak

However, I believe contrary to this is what Rav Dessler writes in מכתב מאליהו חלק א pp. 72

י...כבר היה אדם טרם שנופחה בו נשמתו...ונפשו גדולה מנפשות שאר הברואים, משכלת היא בחכמה, פירוש שיש לו גם שכל וגם כח הדיבור וההסבר מה שאין כן בשאר בעלי חיים. ואחר כך שם בו הקדוש ברוך הוא אל הנשמה הקדושה, היינו כח קדושה עליונה.

...Man existed before the נשמה was blown into him...[Man's] נפש is greater than the נפשות of other creatures, for it is intelligent with wisdom. Meaning, it has both intellect and the ability to speak and to explain. This is not true for other creatures. Afterwards, The Holy One, Blessed is He, placed in [Man] the Holy נשמה, meaning the upper holiness.

Is there a source for what Rav Dessler is saying? It's not what he's focusing on and says it as if it's something that doesn't need explanation. But it is contrary to the sources I'm familiar with.

  • Is this question about the source for the ability to speak as it appears in Torah generally? In other words, how Torah explains the 'evolution' or 'descent' of the power of speech via the aspects of soul which transcend the level of 'Neshama',meaning from the level of 'Chayah' and 'Yechidah'. Or is this about what sources Rav Dessler was using in Michtav M'Eliyahu? Sep 12 '16 at 16:58
  • More the second. Is there an earlier source for such a concept, that before ויפח באפיו there was the ability to speak.
    – robev
    Sep 12 '16 at 17:39
  • see shaarei kedusha part 3 gate 2 "the speaking man was created. He contains all the powers above and additionally a "speaking soul" (nefesh medaberet)"
    – ray
    Sep 12 '16 at 20:22
  • I assume that's the same as the neshama. The Ramban also referred to the neshama as a Nefesh (I didn't quote him in full)
    – robev
    Sep 12 '16 at 23:19
  • 1
    You take the Gra's position as a given, which is appropriate if you're asking a question about a statement by R' Dessler. But according to the Tanya, there is a nefes bahamis (animal soul) and a nefesh E-lokis (G-dly soul), each of which comprised of a nefesh-ruach-neshamah. Just wanted to point out the question isn't as simple as presented; nevermind the answer. Sep 13 '16 at 13:22

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .