4

I was asked to do a children's recreation program at a local Jewish center.

What are suggestions for types of projects to do with a group of children that are allowed to do on Shabbat? Are there any types of crafts to do with the children that are within the limits of Shabbat?

Any ideas of appropriate activities would be greatly appreciated - we have 10-20 school aged children (5-12 years old)

  • 1
    Beth, welcome to Mi Yodeya, and thanks for bringing your question here! Is there a reason that you're specifically looking for craft activities, rather than other activities? I wish you the best of success in creating a program that gives the kids a positive Judaism experience. – Isaac Moses Mar 3 '16 at 0:51
  • 1
    Are you asking for yourself or for the children? The answer may be quite different based on whether you yourself are going to be making the craft (vs. just instructing them) – SAH Mar 3 '16 at 2:23
  • Thanks for the response. On behalf of both parties. I want to make sure I'm within the guidelines. Those of us working in this Recreation project are not Jewish and want to make sure we stay within the boundaries. We have done science experiments which were okayed. Otherwise we just played games that has Legos Hot Wheels foosball table ping pong we will have access to a local gym or we can take the kids over to play more physical games where they would have space to maneuver. The project lasts about 4 hours so we just need enough activities to keep them going. – Beth Mar 10 '16 at 1:53
6

Shabbos laws can be very complicated and many activities that might seem innocent enough superficially can be potentially problematic, at a Rabbinic (d'rabanan), or even at a biblical level (d'orayta), which is why it is important to discuss potential activites first with a competent halachic authority. That said, there are e.g. prohibitions on creating letters, images, or certain structures, all of which can become more severe as the permanence of the creations increase. Many games that do not involve writing, drawing, or measuring, can be fine, though often even these can have potential issues. Most crafts would be a problem inasmuch as something is typically created at a more permanent level (i.e. to be brought home). Depending on the particular community and needs of the children, a competent rabbi may have leniencies for some activities that might be prohibited otherwise.

Chabad.org offers some suggestions here.

  • Thanks. I am looking for any resources that can help me stay within guidelines – Beth Mar 10 '16 at 1:55
3

The Shemirah Shabbath by Rav Yehoshua Neuwirth discusses games and toys in Chapter 16. The closest thing to a crafts which he mentions as permissible for children under bar-bat mitzvah age are

(18) Toy building blocks and

(30) blowing bubbles.

In both cases, he seems to say that it is not permissible for an adult to encourage children to do so. Rather if the children are playing with them, the adults are not required to stop the children. See quotes below.

Therefore, it would be inappropriate to lead children in a formal group.

(18) a. One need not stop children from playing with ordinary toy building blocks or interconnecting blocks of any kind, unless they have to be screwed together or very tightly fixed together, in which case they may not be used.

(30) although adults should not blow soap bubbles, one need not stop children from doing so.

Throughout The chapter he mentions other examples which are fully forbidden. For example,

(4) a. One need not prevent children from playing with sand, provided the sand is of a fine consistency is dry and was prepared for this use before Shabbos as in a sandbox. [But] b. Is not permitted to mix the sand with water or to pour water over it, as this contravenes the prohibition against kneading.

(13) it is forbidden a. to shape models out of plasticine, Clay, wax or the like and b. To pour plaster into any kind of mold.

(19) one should not make boats, hats or other objects by folding paper.

(20) it is not permitted to assemble or dismantle a toy from a model making kit, such as a model airplane or ship made from plastic, metal or wooden parts, as the parts join together with a great deal of precision and they are normally built with the intention of leaving them assembled for a considerable time.

(28) All games involving cutting or sticking, whether with glue or with adhesive tape are prohibited.

(36) Plaiting or weaving together threads, strands or strips of plastic or other material is prohibited one Shabbos and YomTov.

Throughout the chapter he suggests various games, such as

(5) arbles, only on floors not bare earth or ground outside.

(6) Table tennis or ball games inside or out with an Eruv but not on ground, only on hard surfaces;

(11) Playing "5 avanim" (an Israeli game normally played with a set of five blocks but could be played with stones, as long as the stones were set aside for the game before Shabbos or YomTov .)

(23) One is allowed to play games in which letters, or parts of letters or of a picture, are placed side-by-side so as to make up a whole word or picture provided that this does not involve setting the word or picture in a frame that holds it together and the various sections are not interlocked and fixed together as most jigsaw puzzles.

(16) Playing with a game consisting of (usually) 15 movable letters or numbered squares set in a framed board the size of 16 such squares and rearranging the squares by moving them about within the board, is permissible on Shabbos and YomTov.

(33) Dice Games, for example "Chutes and Ladders" are permitted, so long, of course, as they do not involve any for bidden activity.

(34) a. Games like chess, Dominos and "Fish" (a card game in which for cards are dealt to each player and have to be made into sets) are allowed.

b. However care should be taken when play has ended not to separate the pieces or cards by color or type as this contravenes the prohibition against selection.

c. Pieces or cards may be separated and sorted with a view to playing with them right away.

(39) a. Running and jumping games, such as tag, hide and seek and skipping with a rope are permitted, but b. The performance of physical exercises is prohibited as detailed in chapter 14.

Of course, other activities as noted by some of the other answers are also educational and/or fun for children.

  • David Mulder: Thank you for the edit! I'm typing on an iPhone... – R Yisroel Meir Vogel Mar 3 '16 at 17:18
-1

no crafts could be done but there are still plenty of activities. Including learning the parsha, the little midrash says, many other Jewish topics formatted for children, story telling (from a book or ones they made up themselves) games, singing songs

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .