2

When reading Keriat Shema without a minyan, to complete 248 words, the Minhat Ela'zar says that the individual should repeat 'Hashem Elokeikhem Emes'. Is there any drawback to this position? (It's new to me, but seems direct and reasonable, so I'm wondering why it doesn't seem to have caught on.)

2

Some possibilities that come to mind:

  1. hefsek (unnecessary interruption between the Shema and its blessings)
  2. motzi shem shamayim l'vatala (saying the divine name without justification)
  3. going against an established minhag klal yisrael (custom)
  4. going against an established p'sak halacha (assuming the normative ruling is not to)
  • 2
    Re: hefsek, the popular custom of saying 'keil melekh ne'eman' seems to be a hefseik too. – paquda Jan 29 '16 at 15:26
  • 2
    Re: motzi shem shamayim l'vatala, saying 'keil melekh ne'eman' also includes Hashems name. – Gershon Gold Jan 29 '16 at 15:27
  • 2
    Indeed. And I believe that is why many refrain from doing so. You asked if there were any drawbacks. This is a potential one. I am sure there are many who hold that one/the other/neither would be an actual hefsek, akin to Hashkiveinu... – Loewian Jan 29 '16 at 15:28

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .