0

See this M.Y. question for a brief description of "upper" vs. "lower" trope for the 10 Commandments.

Most Nusach Ashkenaz shuls that I have attended use the upper trope while reading the 10 Commandments. The 10 Commandments are read 3 times during the year:

  • Shabbat weekly reading of Yitro
  • 1st day of Shavu'ot
  • Shabbat weekly reading of Va'etchanan

On all 3 occasions, I have heard it read using the "upper" trope.

Are there any communities / nuscha'ot exiting today, that read it using the "lower" trope version, as part of one of the above readings? Do they do this throughout the year or switch it for one of the 3 above occasions? If you know why they do this, (i.e. - lower always or switching), please add this info to your answer.

Are there any halachic opinions that state a preference and / or time to use one version vs. the other?

  • Do you mean as part of the public reading of the Torah? – sabbahillel Jan 25 '16 at 20:13
  • In general Ashkenazim use Taam Elyon only on Shavuot, Sefardim use it whenever reading the Torah, and Teimanim use it even in private. In the last 80 years or so traditions have become sorta mixed, unfortunately (not unlike other Leining issues, like HaZiV LaKh). – Double AA Jan 27 '16 at 19:01

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .