3

See this M.Y. question for a brief description of "upper" vs. "lower" trope for the 10 Commandments.

Most Nusach Ashkenaz shuls that I have attended use the upper trope while reading the 10 Commandments. The 10 Commandments are read 3 times during the year:

  • Shabbat weekly reading of Yitro
  • 1st day of Shavu'ot
  • Shabbat weekly reading of Va'etchanan

On all 3 occasions, I have heard it read using the "upper" trope.

Are there any communities / nuscha'ot exiting today, that read it using the "lower" trope version, as part of one of the above readings? Do they do this throughout the year or switch it for one of the 3 above occasions? If you know why they do this, (i.e. - lower always or switching), please add this info to your answer.

Are there any halachic opinions that state a preference and / or time to use one version vs. the other?

  • Do you mean as part of the public reading of the Torah? – sabbahillel Jan 25 '16 at 20:13
  • In general Ashkenazim use Taam Elyon only on Shavuot, Sefardim use it whenever reading the Torah, and Teimanim use it even in private. In the last century or so traditions have become sorta mixed, unfortunately. – Double AA Jan 27 '16 at 19:01
7

It would seem that original Minhag Ashkenaz was to use ta'am elyon only on Shavu'ot, but on shabbat parashat yitro and shabbat parashat va'etchanan to use ta'am tachton. This can be seen in the commentary of Hizkuni to Shemot 20:14, and is also the practice prescribed by Masat Binyamin, quoted in Magen Avraham 494:1.

Magen Avraham also notes the Sephardic practice, as described by R. Ya'akov ibn Haviv and R. Menahem de Lonzano, to always use ta'am elyon in public.

Interestingly, there seem to be many relatively old examples of Ashkenazim following the Sephardic custom. For example, R. Yoseph b. Moshe writes in Leket Yosher that his teacher R. Yisrael Isserlein would always use ta'am elyon for public reading, and would only use ta'am tachton during private study. Similary, R. Moshe Sofer in Responsa Hatam Sofer Yoreh De'ah 260 implies that ta'am tachton is only used for private study, with ta'am elyon used for all public reading.

As far as why one would differentiate between the reading on Shavu'ot and regular shabbatot, R. Yoseph Dov Soloveitchik, quoted in Reshimot Shi'urim Berachot 12a, suggests that the use of ta'am elyon is to, in a sense, recreate the experience of the Giving of the Torah at Mt Sinai, whereby we read each individual commandment as its own verse. The differing customs then reflect a disagreement as to whether this 'recreation' is only done on Shavu'ot, the anniversary of the Giving of the Torah, or instead whenever the Decalogue is read publically.

Finally, R. Soloveitchik notes that his grandfather, R. Haim Soloveitchik, only ever used ta'am tachton, even on Shavu'ot, as he did not want to break up verses in a different way to (what he believed was) the authentic tradition.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .