4

Before someone drinks a fresh orange juice, which of the following blessings is required to be said? Should the blessing be "shehakol"? "borai pri ha'etz"? or both?

2

According to the Brachot site

Q31) What bracha would one make on orange juice with the pulp bits inside?

A31) Fruit juices generally lose their ha'eitz bracha and become shehakol. Although there has been some discussion why that is so even in cases where the fruits are planted for the sake of the juice (which is how juices are made today) - nevertheless the prevalent minhag ha'olam is to still make shehakol on these fruit juices. As far as the pulp is concerned, it is tafel, or subordinate - because if you wanted the actual fruit then you should just eat the actual fruit..

  • The minority opinion -- ha'etz because those oranges were grown for their juice -- is the Chazon Ish, by the way. – Shalom Nov 4 '15 at 17:52
  • The user specified a "fresh" orange juice suggesting they squeezed it themselves, in which case the orange was probably one grown for eating not squeezing. – CashCow Nov 5 '15 at 17:16
  • @CashCow I inferred that. also, though the definition of "fresh" is ambiguous. Regardless, I think the rules would be the same. What may require research, though, is what happens with oranges grown in the U.S. AFAIK, only certain types of oranges are usable as juice. (They sell them in the store as "juice" oranges. Navel oranges, IIRC, don't make great juice. Admittedly, the above answer may be too "general" and might not be considering this aspect. – DanF Nov 5 '15 at 17:34

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .