1

Can a person break an oath to G-d to save a life?

For example, if someone in the army made an official oath to serve the army and obey the commands always, but one day the person saw his commander trying to kill bunch of innocent people, can he break the oath to save them?

  • 2
    Why might you think he can or can't break the oath? Please edit to clarify. – Double AA Aug 27 '15 at 3:39
5

Your example is politically loaded. Let's try a simpler one.

Joe makes a vow not to eat chocolate. Then he finds himself on a desert island where there is no food other than chocolate, and he will otherwise die of starvation. (Or more simply -- he's having a diabetic emergency and the only available food is chocolate.)

The prohibition of violating a vow is "he shall not violate his word"; the theoretical punishment for doing so is lashes.

The categorical rule of Jewish law is that the only commandments that can't be broken to save a life are murder, idolatry, and a handful of severe sexual offenses. (All of which theoretically carry the death penalty.) I've heard lots of discussions of other exceptions (e.g. what should a judge do if he fears for his life), but never anything about oaths. Therefore saving a life would override an oath. (Furthermore, we believe an oath could be annulled; it would be easy, time permitting, to assemble a rabbinic panel and retroactively regret not having inserted a life-or-death clause into the original oath.)

Questions of to what degree soldiers are expected to follow orders without question, for the broader good of the nation, arise independently of any "oath" -- you're welcome to ask that as a separate question.

  • Even non capital offenses in those categories may be of similar stringency in this regard. – Double AA Aug 27 '15 at 13:56
  • @DoubleAA yes it's discussed; but as "accessories to the sort of sin that could warrant the death penalty." – Shalom Aug 27 '15 at 14:35
  • Yes so your answer is misleading in that regard even if your conclusion is correct. – Double AA Aug 27 '15 at 14:36

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .