4

Can one go out in the street on shabbas(without an eiruv) with a hat that has a feather or pin in the ribbon?

Is it considered a masuaei (load)?

7

If it is serving a decorative function, it's not a problem. (See Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 303 and 310 and Shemirath Shabbath K'Hilkhatha 18:12. Hypothetically, if there's a chance the one wearing it is likely to take it out in reshuth harabim, then there could be a reason to forbid it. See Orach Chaim 303:18. Also, if the hat has a stiff brim that is more than a tefach, that could be a separate problem on Shabbath, possibly even with an eruv [see Talmud Bavli Shabbath 138b; see also Mishna Berurah 301:152.)

See also http://www.atlantakollel.org/article_detail.php?id=201&section=resources:

Wearing a tachshit (in the street) is permitted on the same general principle by which clothing is permitted. Like garments, a tachshit is considered subordinate to a person, almost as though it were a part of the person himself. However, unlike a garment, a tachshit is not permitted unless it is needed, either as an ornament, or to protect his body, or provide physical comfort.

Examples: 1) Ornamental: Jewelry (earrings, necklaces, bracelets, etc.), decorative berets worn in hair, decorative pins, a feather in a hat, a necktie (a necktie is NOT considered a malbush – garment!) 2) Protective: a bandage or a dressing over a wound, cotton in an aching ear, rupture belts, orthodontic braces or dental bite plates.

  • OC 303:18 may apply even without such a chance being at all likely. – Double AA Jul 14 '15 at 16:04
5

I found in the Rivevos Ephraim 4:97:20 this question. Rav Ephraim Greenblatt asked Rav Nochum Kornmehl (Tiferes Tzvi) this question and Rav Greenblatt put it in his sefer:

enter image description here

He answered that one should sew the feather to the hat because one might take the feather out since sometimes one will go out without the feather.

Rav Yisrael Taplin goes through some Piskei Rav Moshe Feinstein and this is one of them:

enter image description here

One should make sure it is snug to the hat so it doesn't fall off in a reshus harabim.

The Be'er Moshe in chelek 3 siman 69 allows one to wear a feather in one's hat on shabbas,however he was not too fond of the idea for a Yiras Shemayim.

enter image description here

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .