When are you forbidden from making a Brocha Rishona on a food item,and obligated to make a Bracha Achrona after eating it?


Obviously, but probably not what you wanted: most food during a meal. They don't require a Brocho Rishonah, and definitely require a Bracha Achronah.

Otherwise, something keeps nagging at my brain like I know it, but just can't place it.

| improve this answer | |
  • This is not counting hamotzi as the b'racha rishona on food during the meal, but is counting birkas hamazon as its b'racha acharona. On what basis, please? – msh210 Feb 20 '11 at 4:55
  • 2
    Well he never said anything about "counting". Just "forbidden" - which is true, and "obligated" - which is also true. Taking into context that this was asked as a riddle, it would certainly fit. – yydl Feb 20 '11 at 5:32
  • You're correct though. If I count it for one I should count it for the other.... Just the way he phrased it. – yydl Feb 20 '11 at 5:32
  • Good point (re "he never said... asked as a riddle..."). – msh210 Feb 20 '11 at 15:28

The earlier answers may be right but not what i was looking for.

The Mishna Berurah in Siman 196 s”k 4 says that if you steal wheat and grind it into flour, although he is required to return it. Hallachicly he is its new owner, nevertheless he may not, make a brocha on food produced from that stolen wheat.The reason for this is based in the concept of “Ein zeh Mevareich elah menaeitz”(he’s not blessing, rather he is being disgusting). This concept is only true for Brocha Rishona; as far as the Bracha achrona is concerned, if one made bread out of stolen wheat and ate to the point of satiation, since he’s now obligated from the Torah to say Birkas Hamazon, he is not absolved of his obligation, and he still has too ‘bentch’.

| improve this answer | |
  • No one actually holds that that is the halacha. The MB brings a machlokes- some say make both brachos, some say make neither. The MB then quotes (part of) the Magen Avraham that, if you ate to satiation so that its a d'oraysa question, you should be machmir to bentch. – YDK Feb 20 '11 at 6:45

I don't know, but, as a guess, something that must be eaten immediately to save a life (e.g., of someone starving).

| improve this answer | |

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .