5

I've often seen people do magic tricks for their nieces, nephews or for children in general. To an adult observer, the trick is obvious - but to young children, it seems like real magic. Considering that it's permissible to perform "magic" for adults as long as it's only to entertain and impress the audience, is this allowed?

  • 2
    Doesn't the first half of your last sentence answer the question? – Scimonster Mar 15 '15 at 16:41
  • @Scimonster I don't think so. The site is referring to entertaining an audience that knows you're just entertaining them. Here, you're entertaining someone that you know will think it's real magic. But then again, maybe it would be okay because they're "just kids." – user6618 Mar 15 '15 at 18:05
  • I thought we had this question here already.... – msh210 Mar 15 '15 at 20:46
  • At the "magic" shows for religious Jewish children that I have seen, the "magicians explains that it is just a trick and anot "real magic". The children are told that they are being tricked and enjoy it. The problem would only be if they are told that it is "real magic". – sabbahillel Mar 15 '15 at 22:31
  • @sabbahillel What about a 3, 4, or 5-year-old child that can't make the distinction between magic and a trick, even when explained? He sees something there, and then sees it not there. – user6618 Mar 15 '15 at 22:45
6

In terms of magic to begin with Rav Moshe Feinstein (Iggros Moshe YD 4:13.) Seems to allow it. But later versions of Iggros Moshe seem to indicate he was hesitant to issue a Heter.

However, the Chochmas Adam (89:6) forbids the practice. Chochmas Adam writes, "...those badchanim (merrymakers) who perform achizas einayim at weddings are transgressing a prohibition of the Torah. One who bids them to do so transgresses the prohibition of lifnei eveir (causing one's fellow man to sin). Anyone who can object to this practice is obligated to do so, and certainly it is prohibited to watch their tricks, since one is aiding transgressors. " The Chochmas Adam's ruling is quoted by many other poskim and none mention that the prohibition may no longer apply in our times.

However, the Maharshal differed with this Chochmas Adam and held that swift hands coupled with sorcery is forbidden. But sleight of hand alone. Is permissible.

Rav Yisroel Belsky (Shulchan Halevi page 138-141) suggests that announcing to the audience beforehand that none of the tricks involve actual sorcery but is just trickery, that maybe even the Chochmas Adam would have permitted it.

The poskim mentioned above do not make a distinction between adults and children. Although, logically if one is going to make a disclaimer, he should explain it in a way that the children in the audience can understand that the tricks are not magical.

However, I did find on this site that mentions without quoting a source that one should not preform for young impressionable children:

Question: In practice, how should we conduct ourselves in regard to magic shows? Discussion: None of the poskim who discuss this issue are quick to permit any type of magic. Indeed, the vast majority of poskim strictly prohibit it, some of them on the grounds that it a Biblical prohibition. Consequently, whenever possible, one should not perform or watch magic tricks, and surely not present magic shows in a school or camp to young, impressionable children. In unique situations when-under direction of a rav-an exception has to be made, we have seen that there are some poskim who are more lenient, provided that the audience clearly understands that no magic is involved. Some poskim add that the magician must also demonstrate how the magic is performed.

Nonetheless, many commentators say that as long as you are not actually preforming magic, even if the audience would be duped into believing it is, it was not forbidden (Radbaz in Metzudas David 61, who maintains that the Torah only prohibits true acts of sorcery, and not deceptive acts that rely on purely natural phenomena. See Betzel Hachochmah 4:13 as well who echoes his opinion) thus even with impressionable children, it would be permitted.

See here as well:

In conclusion, it is worth noting that even those who are stringent regarding “slight of the hands,” may concede that today no prohibition would apply. As the Rambam and the Chinuch (250, at greater length) conclude, the evil of “deception of the eyes” is that people will come to believe the impossible to be possible, and even reach conclusions that contravene the basic Jewish faith.

Nowadays, this scenario is quite implausible—which is perhaps the background to the difference in approach of later authorities, such as the Iggros Moshe and the Klausenberger Rav, in comparison with the stringency of earlier authorities. The first question that a child raises after a magic trick is performed, is “How did you do it?!” He clearly doesn’t believe that the word “abracadabra” in able to achieve miracles, and supernatural forces are surely the last thing on his mind.

See here for further reading: http://www.torah.org/advanced/weekly-halacha/5757/kedoshim.html

  • Well done. I think pretty much no one (pagans/wikkans aside) in modern times considers any real sorcery to be taking place. Would that obviate the need for a disclaimer according to Rav Belsky? – Isaac Kotlicky Mar 15 '15 at 17:11
  • Funny how you ask, I will add that mareh makom of rav belsky where he then has a whole arichus about how we shouldn't think we in our modern age are so smart as to assume that we wouldn't fall for these things and attribute it to sorcery. So clearly the need to make a disclaimer still applies in his viewpoint. Also google "satanic cults nachlaot Sanhedria murchevet for modern applications". – Shoel U'Meishiv Mar 15 '15 at 17:15
  • How does this answer the question? The OU website linked in the question already shows when and why it would be permissible to do magic for an adult. This question is specifically regarding children. – user6618 Mar 15 '15 at 18:08
  • @user6618 thats the point, theres no reason to assume there is a distinction. the possibility to believe its magic is an issue whether child or adult, but seemingly making a disclaimer (i would assume in a way that makes it clear and simple even to a child, but thats practical in terms of how you phrase the disclaimer, and is dependent on sechel, no halacha should have to tell you that) rids the problem of Kishuf – Shoel U'Meishiv Mar 15 '15 at 18:20
  • Let us continue this discussion in chat. – user6618 Mar 15 '15 at 19:26

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .