8

Where can one find the 'disputation of Barcelona' between Pablo Cristiani and the Ramban?

14

The best (English language) source, in my opinion, is Hyam Maccoby's Judaism on Trial: Jewish-Christian Disputations in the Middle Ages (Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 1982; later adapted as a play viewable here). In it you will find a translation of the Ramban's Vikuach, and of the official church account of that disputation, together with an extensive introduction and commentary. The Ramban's Vikuach is also translated by R' Dr Charles B. Chavel, and published as The Disputation at Barcelona (Shilo Publishing House, 1983).

The original Hebrew text is found in Kitvei haRamban I, pp302-320 (ed. Steinschneider, 1860).

2

It's in the Kisvei HaRamban. Volume 1, I think.

  • Correct, the Ramban's account can be found in volume 1 of R' Chavel's Kisvei Ramban (cited here). It can also be found in Otzar Vikuchim, here. – Fred Jan 26 '15 at 2:22
0

The first publication of the Vikuah is found in Tela Ignea Satanae (Altdorf, 1681), a book with polemics edited by a xtian hebraist named Johann Christoph Wagenseil followed by a latin translation of the dispute.

Its text has interpolated expressions by jewish copyists, however this gives a sense of what occurred in the jewish mentality given the missionary efforts in those times.

See the edition here in pages 24 ff.

0

The disputation was also included by J.D. Eisenstein in his anthology "אוצר ויכוחים", "Polemics and Disputations.

The Ramban's debate can be found on pp.86-94.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .