2

Say you are about to perform some action. You then realize that there might be some halachic issues involved. You begin to enter a thought process about what is the halachically right thing to do.

Does entering this thought process count towards Talmud Torah, even if there is no speech involved?

closed as unclear what you're asking by mevaqesh, sabbahillel, Gershon Gold, DonielF, Yaacov Deane Jun 9 '17 at 14:19

Please clarify your specific problem or add additional details to highlight exactly what you need. As it's currently written, it’s hard to tell exactly what you're asking. See the How to Ask page for help clarifying this question. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

3

The Maharal in Nesiv HaTorah towards the end of chapter 4 writes that one does not need to make a Birkas haTorah on thoughts of Torah. The Maharal explains that this is because a person is defined by speech, as Onkelos translates ויהי האדם לנפש חיה, Man became a living being, as רוח ממללא, a speaking being. Man is defined by the intersect between the intellect and the body, which is exemplified in the bringing out of the thought into speech, which requires the combination of intellect and action (this is expanded in Gevuros Hashem ch. 28). The intellect, and therefore thought, is not really part of the person (this is expanded on in ch. 9), and therefore involvement in Torah in thought is not really the person himself being involved. It is only through speech that the person is considered to himself be involved in Torah.

The Maharal does not explicitly say that this is not considered Talmud Torah, but the implication of not requiring the Birkas haTorah implies that this is not a fulfillment of the mitzvah of Talmud Torah.

  • Do we paskin this way? If we did then anyone reading a torah book without verbalizing the words would not be fulfilling Talmud Torah. – Ani Yodea Jan 20 '15 at 20:41
  • @AniYodea I don't know how "we" pasken, but this site isn't for paskening. In any event, the Maharal there brings several reasons why you should be learning out loud anyways. – Y     e     z Jan 20 '15 at 20:43
  • By we I mean the modern day poskim - not the users of this site. – Ani Yodea Jan 20 '15 at 20:44
  • 1
    @AniYodea fulfilling the mitzvah of talmud Torah and the requirement to make birkas hatorah are not necessarily the same. It's a complicated issue – הנער הזה Jan 20 '15 at 23:29

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .