It appears that you can use live fish for kapparos. How is this done?

  • Holding the fish in hand (really quickly)?
  • Holding the fish in a towel?
  • Holding the fish in a bowl?

Answers sourced both in rabbinic literature and practical experience are welcome.


1 Answer 1


since the fish is considered killed when between the fins the area of a sela coin dries (shulchan aruch harav 316.13) probably the only option that you gave that will work is "Holding the fish in a bowl"

ps maybe a wet towel will work

pps the maharal mi prag brings that the source of kaparot from gemoro is the Rabbi Akiva (ish gam zu)'s story with the donkey chicken and candle (last paragraph on the page, if you are lazy you can start from the end next page 7 lines from the end of the fist paragraph)

ppps opinion that main thing in the kaporos is shechita (see last paragraph on the page)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .