4

Is there a nusach hat'fila in which the 16th b'racha of the amida begins with "אב הרחמן" at shacharis only and skips those words at other t'filos?

I heard recently that this is in fact printed in some version of the Artscroll Siddur but I have not seen it inside.

Why would this be so? Isn't one consistent with nusach S'farad and the other with nusach Ashkenaz?

1

It sounds at first glance as if someone is confused and mixed up Av Harahaman of Shema Koleinu with Ahavah Rabbah of Ahavas Olam in which indeed we find some Hasidim switching to Ahavah Rabbah for Shabbos Shaharis.

  • @Yahu I wouldn't rule out confusion. Is it fair to assume that the presence or absence of "שמע קולנו" correlates 100% with נוסח? – WAF Dec 19 '10 at 16:05
  • My understanding was that "Av Harahaman, Shemah Kolainu" is what is said, and not skipping "Shemah Kolainu". – Yahu Dec 19 '10 at 20:42

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .