2

If every meal on shabbos is a seudas mitzvah why does sudas shilshis not have the honor of having a kiddush?

  • Why should seudas mitzva status necessitate kiddush – Double AA Sep 29 '14 at 21:51
  • 1
    Sometimes the third meal on shabbat does require Kiddush. The only meals that require kiddush accd to ShA are the first meal at night and the first meal in the day. – Double AA Sep 29 '14 at 21:53
1

According to the Tur's OC 291 reading of the Rambam Shabbas 30:9 one should recite kiddush by the third meal and so did the Shibulei Haleket's Rebbi(Rav Meir Bar Moshe). See the Kesef Hamishna 4 who disagrees with such a reading and brings many opinions. He adds that one who is makdish does not lose anything.

The Shibulei Haleket explains why we don't say kiddush by the third meal in Siman 93(don't have access now to it to read it)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .