3

Is it permissible to put Soup Mandels in hot (Yad Soledes) soup on Shabbos, assuming the soup bowl was filled in a standard way - pot taken off of fire, soup ladle inserted into pot and soup removed and put into the bowl in which it is served.

Sample Soup Mandel

6
  • Ein Bishul Achar Bishul, no? Why do you suspect there would be a problem?
    – Double AA
    Jul 9, 2014 at 22:06
  • @DoubleAA, I don't know the manufacturing process for these. In addition ...
    – Yishai
    Jul 9, 2014 at 22:11
  • 1
    They are deep fried, AFAIK. I don't see why your link is relevant as the heat doesn't melt anything here.
    – Double AA
    Jul 9, 2014 at 22:14
  • @DoubleAA, sounds like an answer ...
    – Yishai
    Jul 9, 2014 at 22:14
  • @DoubleAA If they are deep fried it is an issue, as yesh bishul achar tzli, no? Or does deep frying specifically constitute bishul because the item is enveloped in the oil?
    – Yehuda
    Aug 24, 2021 at 0:01

3 Answers 3

3

Yes. You can even put it in a cli rishon that's off the fire.

שקדיות מרק ... הנמכרות כשהן מוכנות לאכילה, מותר לתת אפילו בכלי ראשון, אם אינו עומד על גבי האש...

Soup mandels ... that are sold ready to eat, it is permissible to place them even in a cli rishon, if it is not on the fire. (Translation mine)

Source: Shmirat Shabbat C'Hilchata, 1:61

3

HaRav Chaim Bleier shlita in his Chukei Chaim series here (on page 2) addresses this question.

He writes as follows:

Adding Croutons or Soup Nuts to Soup on Shabbos

Croutons and noodles. Deep-fried soup croutons, which are considered cooked1, may be added to soup on Shabbos, even if it is yad soledes bo (מאור השבת ח"ב סי' ח' סק"ה) since we pasken ‘ein bishul achar bishul’ with dry foods (שו"ע סי' שי"ח ס"ד) The same applies to noodles....

Soup nuts. Although soup nuts are also deep-fried and have the same status (מו"ר בשו"ת שבט הקהתי ח"א סי' ק"ט), some are uncertain about them since the oil stays on their surface and does not permeate them; perhaps they should be considered baked, not entirely cooked, and adding them to hot soup would involve an issur of bishul achar afiyoh, which is a matter of dispute (ב' דיעות בשו"ע סי' שי"ח ס"ה) and should be avoided lechatchilo (רמ"א שם). Therefore it is best to put them into a kli shlishi, not a kli sheini (שו"ת שבט הלוי ח"ז סי"ב). Nevertheless, when considering that soup transferred from a pot to a bowl with a ladle may be a kli shlishi (מ"ב סי' שי"ח סקפ"ז), one may rely on this and be meikel for bishul achar afiyoh (מ"ב שם סקמ"ה).


1 Store-bought croutons made in a factory by deep-frying small pieces of bread have the status of less than a kezayis of cooked bread and are mezonos (שו"ע סי' קס"ח ס"י, הגרשז"א שש"כ פ"א סס"א). Even if they were fried in a bit of oil, not deep-fried, they are mezonos since they were made with bread baked specifically for croutons (מדריך הכשרות עדה"ח תשע"ז עמ' 162).

2
  • The link in shevet hakehati is to a responsum about taking medicine before Kiddush...?
    – Double AA
    Aug 24, 2021 at 2:59
  • Your right?! It must have been a typo - I'll have a look if I can find the right siman
    – Dov
    Aug 24, 2021 at 8:06
0

When the pot is taken off the fire, it is still a kli rishon. The soup ladel is a kli sheni and the bowl a kli shlishi.

However:

  1. If the soup ladel gets as hot as the soup it may be a kli rishon as well.
  2. Not everybody holds of a kli shlishi.
  3. If the soup has a davar gush in it, e.g. noodles or kreplach, the davar gush may be treated like a kli rishon. It is unclear if that changes the status of the soup.
  4. If frying is like cooking, the rule ain bishul achar bishul should apply.
  5. If frying is like baking, it is a machlokes whether there is bishul achar afiyah.

As such, it depends on what you hold and how machmir you are on Shabbos. Either way you have who to rely on. IIUC, most people are lenient.

4
  • Not everyone agrees a ladel is kli sheni. See Taz YD 94
    – Double AA
    Jul 9, 2014 at 23:14
  • 1
    Who holds deep frying is like baking???
    – Double AA
    Jul 9, 2014 at 23:14
  • @DoubleAA actually, i don't remember. :( Maybe i'm remembering incorrectly. Also, i think there is a difference in whether the oil completely covers the item or not. Jul 9, 2014 at 23:26
  • The question about whether frying is like cooking or baking is only when there is a little oil in the pan. However when you cook something in oil, what is called "deep frying" in our parlance, there is complete agreement that this is considered cooking
    – Jewels
    Jul 10, 2014 at 5:55

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .