5

There is a commonly quoted anecdote that when Vice President Hubert Humphrey came to the Satmar Rav for votes in 1968 and asked him what he could do for him the Satmar Rav replied "Sell weapons to Israel!". In some versions of the story Humphrey is surprised about this and the Satmar Rav explains "We have a disagreement with our family members but we don't want to see them hurt". This anecdote seems to be popular because it contradict (or at least mitigates) the uncompromising anti-Zionism that is reflected in R' Yoelish's published writings. My question is does anyone have a reliable source for this story and is it true? And if not where does this story come from?

closed as off-topic by רבות מחשבות, Alex, DonielF, sabbahillel, mbloch Apr 5 '18 at 3:41

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

  • "This question does not appear to be about Judaism within the scope defined in the help center. Note that not all questions about the Hebrew language, about history or news of the Jewish people, about Jewish individuals, or about the State of Israel are necessarily about Judaism." – רבות מחשבות, Alex, DonielF, sabbahillel, mbloch
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 1
    This sounds very suspect to me. If that were true, it would not be in spite of what he published - it would be in direct contradiction. A desire for a strong State of Israel!? I would be astonished if he ever expressed such a thing... – Shimon bM Jul 18 '13 at 12:38
  • Suspiciously out of character of the Satmar Rav to say this... – ezra Aug 23 '16 at 22:20
  • 1
    Seems to be about Jews and History; not Judaism. – mevaqesh Aug 24 '16 at 1:40
15

The Satmar book, The Rebbe, mentions a different version of that story. The Rebbe is quoted as saying:

Had Humphrey spoken to me in support of the Zionist state, it wouldn't have bothered me in the least. We Jews have a Torah which forbids us to have a state during the exile, and therefore we may not ask the Americans to support the state. But a non-Jew has no Torah, and by supporting the state he feels he is helping Jews. So, on the contrary, if an American non-Jew is against the Zionist state, it shows he is an anti-Semite.

Cited on http://www.jewishideasdaily.com/824/features/the-riddle-of-the-satmar/

1

Neither story is accurate; the Satmar Rebbe's remark has been completely misconstrued. The real story was simply that during his visit, Humphrey spoke of his support for Israel and the Rebbe simply smiled. When asked afterwards, the Rebbe said "that's just his way of saying he's not an antisemite".

All the other variations of this story are Zionist inventions.

Source: people who spoke to people who were present.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .