I remember reading a responsum on the issue of agnostic Jew's serving as the tenth for a minyan, but do not remember the outcome. Does anyone know the rule?

Also, do we count, as the tenth man, a tinok shenishbah and one who does not understand the prayers at all?

  • If it is permitted, would it be different for a lower level of chiyuve (obligation) for a minyan such as Maariv?

  • If it is forbidden, would it be different for a higher level of chiyuve for a minyan such as Zimun, or someone who has a chiyuve for kaddish.

  • 1
    Igros Moshe OC 1:23 – sam Jul 30 '13 at 3:28
  • I doubt I'll get a response but is this question concerning an agnostic atheist or an agnostic theist? – user6591 Nov 2 '14 at 22:38
  • I think I originally asked about atheists and someone changed the question, but this is a hypothetical (though common occurrence in many places I have been) so I would like to know opinions for both. – Yaakov Pinsky Nov 3 '14 at 20:36
  • See also judaism.stackexchange.com/q/56913 – msh210 Mar 30 '15 at 17:02

Sam gave this source in a comment last year, but no-one ever came to post an answer, so i'll do that now...

In Igrot Moshe OC 1:23, he paskens that בשעת הדחק - in an emergency, someone who is publicly Mechallel Shabbat can be counted for a minyan, to say Barchu, Kadish, and Kedusha. However, for Torah reading, it is more important to have 10 religious Jews.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Two points. Reb Moshe was discussing a michalel shabbos as you mentioned and made a comparison to a kopher a point you left out which is probably important being that we can all be left wondering if an agnostic is comparable to a true kopher or a michalel shabbos. Second, are you sure he said what you wrote about Krias Hatorah? – user6591 Nov 2 '14 at 22:20
  • Thank you, answer still does not refer to someone who does not know what he is answering as he does not know the language etc. – Yaakov Pinsky Nov 3 '14 at 20:37

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .