3

Originally, Yizkor was said on Yom Kippur and only later was it extended to Shelosh Regalim. Why was it not said on Rosh Hashanah which is Yom Hazikkoron? It would seem more appropriate to say it then rather than on Shelosh Regalim, as it is contrary to the spirit of 'veSomachta beChagecha'.

2
  • I heard in a lecture yesterday by Rabbi Richard Sarason that what would become yizkor actually started at Shavuot (based on the date of a crusade-pogrom in the Rhineland) and then expanded to Yom Kippur, but it was a passing comment and I didn't ask for a source. (He didn't talk about the other occurrences.) Nov 6, 2012 at 13:45
  • @TamirEvan, thanks -- I hadn't seen that page, but it contains much of what I heard him say, plus the page has the all-important footnote. Nov 6, 2012 at 18:41

3 Answers 3

2

Divrei Torah Volume 3 #61 mentions a reason that I have heard - which he says is inaccurate. The reason he mentions is that Yom Kippur is like the last day of Rosh HaShana and we always say it on the last days of the Yom Tov. He says that is not accurate as they are separate Yomim Tovim. He then says that on Rosh HaShana we are only supposed to think of live things כי בר״ה יחשבו רק מעניני חיים and through that we will be written to life.

0

The reason I always remember hearing when I was younger (and I apologise for the lack of a source), is that the yizkor of shalosh regalim is connected to the krias hatorah of asser te'asser / kol habechor, where we have the phrase "ish kematnas yado" - each man should give according to his ability. This relates to the practice of committing to donating money to tzedakah as part of yizkor.

Since this is the krias hatorah for the final day of pesach, the second day of shavuos, and shemini atzeres (in chutz la'aretz) the custom arose to extend the recital of yizkor to those days, and not rosh hashanah, where it is not read.

0

Rosh Hashanah: Yizkor is not recited on Rosh Hashanah, neither on the first day or the second day.[Shaareiy Ephraim 10:31; Nitei Gavriel Aveilus 78:7; Divrei Torah 3:61] Nevertheless, the Chabad Rebbeim were accustomed to reciting Yizkor in silence on the second day of Rosh Hashanah.[Toras Menachem 1989 2:284; 1983 1:56; brought in Shulchan Menachem 3:94] Each person may decide whether to follow this custom on Rosh Hashanah.

2
  • That some individuals in a particular community privately conducted themselves contrary to the general custom may be an interesting side-note, but it does not seem to answer the question. Sep 18, 2023 at 11:51
  • Agreed. But it is nevertheless good to have such additional information. Oct 30, 2023 at 23:52

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .