5

How do the words "ממה נפשך" mean what they mean, i.e. "either way"?

closed as off-topic by mevaqesh, mbloch, sabbahillel, DonielF, Gershon Gold Oct 25 '17 at 16:09

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

  • "Questions about the Hebrew language or about history or news of the Jewish people, Jewish individuals, or the State of Israel, except as related to Judaism, are off-topic. If this question does relate to Judaism, please edit it to indicate how." – mevaqesh, mbloch, sabbahillel, DonielF, Gershon Gold
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

4

My understanding has always been:

"ממה נפשך" literally means "From what your soul/self," which is short for "[You may interpret this] from what[ever approach] your self [prefers]."


The closest entry in The Practical Talmud Dictionary is for "מה נפשך," which R' Frank translates as "What is your desire [to say]?!" or "Which position would you adopt?!" - a rhetorical question that implies that whichever of the two positions about to be offered you choose, you'll end up losing.

It could be that "ממה נפשך" is just a variant form of the same expression, or that the extra 'מ' indicates that your position is about to be attacked "from" (or by) a "מה נפשך" argument.

The Dictionary cross-references its entry on "נפש," one of the senses of which is desire/wish. R' Frank gives the same example of this meaning in Biblical Hebrew that Shalom does.

  • We find for instance "malin oso miMa Nafshach" -- we can do circumcision on this baby, FROM a "what is your desire" argument. – Shalom Jul 19 '10 at 11:34
5

אם יש את נפשכם לקבור את מתי מלפני

I think "nefesh" / "soul" can sometimes mean "will" or "desire." "From whatever your desire; if you say it's A, then it works, if you say it's B, then it also works."

0

This term is used when there is a kushya i.e. difficulty on the both צדדים i.e possible sides. This definition is by Darchei Hatalmud (or Hagemara) by Rabbi Yitzchak Kanpanton. The "instruction" of this term is for you to understand clearly what are the difficulties on both sides. See if it is a chiddush( i.e.new idea) to be able to ask the kushya. Do you have to accept certain premises in order to be able to ask the kushya?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .