If someone gets sick during a meal, assuming they are not incapacitated as a result, should they still Bentch, or do we say that they did not gain any nourishment and it's like they didn't eat (or at least like they didn't eat enough to constitute a meal)?

  • 2
    101% chance the Minchat Chinuch has 17 cases which are variations of this.
    – Double AA
    Oct 3, 2012 at 4:11
  • 1
    @DoubleAA See Minchas Chinuch (313).
    – Fred
    Oct 3, 2012 at 4:15
  • @Fred Good find! (I added a link into your comment)
    – Double AA
    Oct 3, 2012 at 4:19

1 Answer 1


See Har Tz'vi (OC 1:163) where he discusses this issue. He first quotes the Panim M'iros (2:27), Chasam Sofer (OC 127), and the Minchas Chinuch (313), who hold that hana'as mei'av is a necessary criterion for birkas hamazon. Therefore, these opinions hold, if someone ate half of a k'zayis, then vomited it up, then ate another half k'zayis, he would be exempt from birkas hamazon (see also Chullin 103b). The Har Tz'vi infers from these opinions that if someone ate a k'zayis at one time, there might be grounds to say that birkas hamazon is required.

However, he then quotes the Gra (Kol Eliyahu, § 9), who writes that if someone vomited out all of what he ate, he is exempt from birkas hamazon because this is similar to a case of delaying bentching until after the food is digested (whereupon one can no longer bentch).

The responsum concludes by referencing the Imrei Binah (OC, § 14), who writes that even if a person kept a little bit of the k'zayis down, he should not bentch because kdei sviah does not remain in his digestive tract.

See also Torah Lishmah (§ 125), who writes that someone who vomits, if he won't be able to eat more and keep it down, should bentch without shem u'malchus.

  • What does he mean in regards to being full for kiddush? When is anybody ever full during kiddush, a person only eats after kiddush?
    – user6591
    Dec 28, 2022 at 3:48
  • @user6591 He's probably talking about a case where someone was eating a meal on Erev Shabbos and continued it into kiddush. Some kind of poreis mappa um'kadeish situation (P'sachim 100a).
    – Fred
    Dec 28, 2022 at 4:19
  • Ah. Makes sense. Ty
    – user6591
    Dec 28, 2022 at 16:42

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .