5

The other simanim eaten on Rosh Hashana contain a play on words with the name of the food and either a wish for a good omen or a wish for bad to befall our enemies. The yehi ratzon for the apple has no such play on words. Why not? And then, why do we eat the apple at all (not mentioned in the gemarah in krisus).

  • It may be nothing more than we don't have a good pun for it. Chazal weren't creative enough. I don't know. You try. – DonielF Apr 6 '17 at 1:27
1

Since Apple in Honey is the only one of these Yehi-Ratzon that Chabad says, it must be unique, and presumably has a different reason/origin from the rest.

  • 1
    Who says Chabad says only that one? The Shulchan Aruch HaRav lists all of them – b a Aug 30 '12 at 1:47
  • 1
    @ba Chabad eats them, just not with a "Yehi-Ratzon". Look at footnote כב – Ariel Aug 30 '12 at 5:11
0

We wish to have a sweet year. We symbolize this with sweet food: apples, honey. Thus, no pun is necessary.

A pun is necessary for, say, leek, since it lacks sweetness.

Dates would, I suppose, not need a pun, since they're sweet — but we can get a pun in, too, so we do.

Source: my own conjecture.

You must log in to answer this question.