4

This question already has an answer here:

Why is there a custom to hang up flowers and growing green things on shavuot?

marked as duplicate by Double AA May 16 '18 at 11:49

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

3

You guys are mixing up two separate minhogim.

One minhog is for grasses/flowers, as a commemoration of the teaching that on Har Sinai at matan Torah there were grass and flowers (recall that it was in the desert).

A second minhog is to have tree branches. That is related to the teaching in the mishna that Shavuos is day of judgement for fruit of trees (peiros hailan). Some congregations do not do it since the GR"A (Vilna Gaon) held that it should not be observed.

  • Please write your sources and if possible link to the source (such as apage on www.hebrewbooks.org ) – Yahu May 21 '10 at 3:12
2

Okay, I'll give the full answer:

Flowers are not mentioned in any of the original sources for these minhagim.

As Mordechai said there are more than one minhag being jumbled together in this question.

A. Minhag to spread herbs in the shul and homes as a reminder of the simha (happiness) of the giving of the Torah. It is a rememberance of this event because there were grasses and herbs growing by Har Sinai (even though it was in the desert, as Mordechai pointed out.) That is why it was necessary for the command to be given not to graze the sheep and cattle near the mountain.

(SA, OC, 494, 3 in Rema and ibid. in MB SK 10)

B. Minhag to distribute herbs that have a scent for people to make a bracha on and smell. I have not yet found a reason specific to Shavuos.

(MB Ibid.)

C. Minhag to set up trees in the shuls and homes as a reminder that on Atzeres (Shavuos) we are judged regarding tree fruit. Based on how this minhag is worded, it is no wonder that the G"RA was against continuing it! Imagine a "Shavuos Tree" in all of our living rooms and in our Shuls! This is the only minhag of the three that it is said that the G"RA was against continuing.

(MB Ibid.)

  • And the reason for the Gra's opposition to the "Shavuos trees" would be because of it's similarity to an Xmas tree, right? An interesting question would be if the Shavuos tree idea came from non-Jewish customs... – ezra Feb 8 '18 at 2:39
  • This is cute, but not correct, unfortunately. It's all one Minhag (to put out greenery) with different preferred species in different locations. Christmas trees weren't even popular back then. See here – Double AA May 16 '18 at 12:01
-1

As a memorial to Har Sinai where there was all types of trees.

  • as well as flowers – yydl May 18 '10 at 19:41
  • Neither trees mentioned by Har Sinai, nor flowers. See my answer. – Yahu May 26 '10 at 19:54

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .