1

In my very vivid dreams, I interact with many real and imaginary characters - some are my living and dead relatives, some are people from my past and present, people I've seen on TV and the Internet, and some are complete strangers I've never met.

I've heard some sources that suggest that during sleep, the soul detaches from the body and has some time of an independent existence that is linked to dreaming.

In Jewish tradition, if I am me/my soul, who are those other characters, where do they come from into my dreams, and who/what animates them?

7
  • Where did you hear this?
    – Rabbi Kaii
    Commented Sep 3 at 14:56
  • @RabbiKaii As a commentary to Brochos 57b - sleep is 1/60th of death.
    – Al Berko
    Commented Sep 3 at 15:07
  • 1
    They are figments of your imagination, and like most people's dreams, are meaningless.
    – N.T.
    Commented Sep 3 at 21:42
  • 1
    Dreams are 1/60th of prophecy, says the Talmud. The rest, presumably, is meshugas. Commented Sep 4 at 1:41

1 Answer 1

4

Derech Hashem 3:1:6, a classical work by the Ramchal, that dips its toe into some Kabbalah, as well as other earlier traditions, gives us many entry routes into this question. I will summarise at the end:

And note that when man sleeps, his faculties rest and his emotions are quiet; and his intellect also rests and is quiet. Only his imagination is active and goes and imagines and creates content according to what comes to it from the remnant of what he depicts during the time he is awake and from what comes to it from the vapors and gases that go up to his brain - whether from the natural humors or whether from foods. And this is the matter of everyone's dreams. But the Creator, may He be blessed, also embedded into it that the higher spirit that we mentioned slightly remove itself at this time from its physical connections at this time. So portions of itself - down to the essence - arise and separate from the body. And only one part - which is the spirit - remains with the lower spirit. And behold, the separated portions float, according to what is allowed them, and encounter and interact with spiritual entities - whether with supervisors of nature or with angels of prophetic reception or with demons, according to what comes to it from one of the various causes. And sometimes the content that it grasps is drawn down and unfolds to the lower spirit, such that an image is aroused and creates content according to its ways. Yet it is possible that the content that it grasps be true or false, due to the intermediaries through which it grasped it. And this content itself is drawn down to the imagination: Sometimes it is conceived of with great confusion, and much jumbling with the empty images that are drawn from the vapors; though sometimes it is with great clarity. And even information and foreknowledge about what will happen to a man in the future can reach him in these ways. And this happens according to His decree, may He be blessed, such that He informs the soul through one of His servants of any given type, and the content gets to the spirit in its imagination - either obscurely or clearly, based on what is decreed by the Supreme Wisdom. And about this matter is it stated (Job 33:15-16) , "In a vision of a dream at night, etc... He then open s the ear of people." It comes out that dreams of imaginative content are either from [the imagination] itself or from that which is aroused by the soul according to that which it grasps. However in all [of the latter], the action is only from one of the spiritual forces that informs the soul. Then the soul brings it down to the imagination, as we have written. And if the force is from the holy servants, the thing will be true; whereas if it is from the opposite forces, the matter will be false. And this is what is written (Berakhot 55b), "Here it was through an angel, but there it was through a demon." But all of them contain some mixture of empty images that are only from the imagination. And that is what is written (Berakhot 55a), "It is impossible for a dream to be without idle things." However there are other dreams that exist, and they are prophetic dreams. [Translation by Rabbi Francis Nataf]

Human beings have a faculty called "imagination" in their intellect (as part of their soul, and this is connected with the Limbic system in the brain), and it is able to form the imagery we see in dreams, including the characters in those dreams.

Another point is that portions of our soul leave our bodies when we sleep and interact with spiritual forces. While we do not experience this consciously, or remember it, it can lead to influence that passes down our soul links until it reaches the part of the soul that never left the body, and then into the imagination.

This is all dependant on Hashem's decree. If He wants a true or false matter to be transmitted to a persons' dreams, He arranges that this should happen. This can include information about the future.

Nonetheless, it doesn't seem this sort of experience will necessarily lead to the actual spiritual forces themselves featuring in our dreams, or any other entities. Ultimately it is still taking place in the imagination, either clearly or obscurely, and the characters in our dreams are still conjured up, even if they are images of real people and real events.

3
  • Nice, so in the mid-18th century rabbis started to get the physiology of sleep with "the vapors and gases that go up to his brain". [As usual] he seemingly contradicts himself by presenting the dreams as both random fumes and divine guidance. But thanks for finding it! Really appreciate +1!
    – Al Berko
    Commented Sep 4 at 9:38
  • @AlBerko Pleasure, as always. Regarding your comments, people can faint from dehydration, or from having a prophetic experience. Contradiction? If not, then why is the fact that dreams can have multiple causes a contradition? Secondly, the tradition of foods and vapours causing dreams is much older than the 18th century in Jewish thought
    – Rabbi Kaii
    Commented Sep 4 at 10:13
  • 1
    Fair enough. I deleted it.
    – Al Berko
    Commented Sep 4 at 17:18

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .