If one began eating out of the Sukkah, and only remembered to eat in the Sukkah once he has less than a כביצה left to eat, must he go eat it in the Sukkah?

Or what about vice versa - if one began eating inside the Sukkah, may he eat outside of it once he is left with only less than a כביצה?

  • How much did he eat already? If only with the remainder it is a כביצה, wouldn't that obligate him no to eat it outside of the sukkah?
    – אילפא
    Oct 9, 2023 at 20:28

1 Answer 1


He doesn't have to eat it, but if he continues to eat it, it must be done in the sukka, because each eating is forbidden. Especially if its toch achilas pas within the other bread he ate. If its not toch cdei achilas pas, that seems to be a subject of a machlokes achronim, if thats also assur to eat out of the sukka. Rav shmuel Kamenetsky ( and many others) holds its assur to eat a cbeiza outside a sukka, even more then cdei achilas pas. Rav Nissim karelitz seems to say the mateh Ephraim matirs it.

The latter case also seems to be dependent on this as well..Also it might be assur because it's within your meal, as proved by the shar hatzion 636 siman 2.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .