I have just done some learning on this and a question I didn't see answered was the following case:

One has a mixture of food, let's say a stew. They decided that the Ikar was the meat, and the carrots are Tofel (e.g. following the halacha in Yalkut Yosef 212:17, the carrots are just there to enhance the flavour of the meat), so they said shehakol. This therefore covers all of the vegetables as well according to the laws of Tofel and Ikar (see Yalkut Yosef 212, Shulchan Aruch O.C 212).

What happens if at various points during the dining, the person eating is going to be eating the vegetables by themselves a lot?

Example: the person sticks fork into a pile and pulls out just a carrot and eats it.
Example: the person deliberately makes up some spoonfuls composed of just carrots.
Example: the person finishes all the meat quickly, and now has just a (not tiny) quantity of carrots left, which he proceeds to eat.

In any of these cases or similar, does one need to make a boreh peri ha'adama on the vegetables?

I would guess from YY 212:18, 19 and especially 20, that this person should probably say boreh peri ha'adama from the start on the carrots, and it is not a beracha she'en tzericha, but given the wording, I am not sure. That conclusion is also questionable because it seems like Tofel and Ikar is quite a fragile halacha, i.e. some of the places where I see it applied such as 212:17 itself might fall under scrutiny if we say that he should bless on the carrots here... If every time I have a mixture of foods I separate out everything and make individual berachot, what is the point of Tofel V'Ikar, aside from the very different cases like condiments and cheese on crackers?


1 Answer 1


The first two examples you mentioned, are discussed by the Aruch Hashulchan 212:2 where he differentiates if it so happened that a spoonful came out with only one of them, or if you deliberately picked out a spoonful of the taful to eat it separately

דאין זו שאלה, דבטפילה המעורבת לא שייך עיקר וטפל אלא כשאוכלם ביחד, כמו כשמבשלים גרויפי"ן עם קטניות או עם תפוחי אדמה שלוקחין בכף אחת זה וזה, ואז אפילו אם אינו נלקח בכף רק מין אחד גם כן הוי טפל. אבל הבשר אוכלין בפני עצמו או קודם התבשיל או אחר כך, אין זה עיקר וטפל. והוא הדין אם ליקט התפוחי אדמה מתוך התבשיל ואוכלן בפני עצמם - מברך עליהם 'בורא פרי האדמה' אם התבשיל ברכתו 'מזונות' או 'שהכל', וכן להיפך בבשר כשחתכן לחתיכות קטנות ואוכלן ביחד עם התבשיל - נעשים בטילים וטפלים להתבשיל וכיוצא בזה בכל הדברים.

The third example you mentioned, when the taful is left over by itself, the MB 168:46 says that would not require a bracha since it is still considered part of the ikar

מו פוטרתן - ואם אכל המרקחת מלמעלה והשאיר הרקיקין ואכלן בפני עצמן צריך לברך במ"מ עליהם אך אם אכלן ביחד ונשאר עוד קצת רקיק בלא מרקחת אין צריך לברך עליו כיון דעיקר אכילתו היה ביחד ונחשב לטפל להמרקחת אין חוששין על גמר האכילה:

  • Translation pls? May 10, 2023 at 18:48

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .