2

Noach and Shem were alive during the time of Avraham, and I know midrashim say he lived in their house for some time learning about Hashem, but how come the whole world was practicing polytheism, when there were witnesses to monotheism, and they would have passed it down generations? How could people have “come up” with Avodah Zarah, when monotheism should have been brought down through the generations?

1

1 Answer 1

2

Hi and welcome to Mi Yodeya. The short answer is that people who never spoke to Hashem aren't necessarily going to believe others who claim they did. However, given that it was indeed so generationally close to Adam, I still agree it needs more explanation and so does the Rambam in the first halachot of Avodah Zara in Mishneh Torah.

To summarise, first realise that this happened over several steps, over a long time. As modern social media informs us, even in an age of unlimited access to information, people are still so easily convinced to totally get behind a philosophy, on the tiniest shreds of evidence and convincing. So the following is totally, utterly reasonable:

Step 1: Well intentioned-mistakes. People made a great mistake and decided that Hashem would want us to honour His honoured stars and planets. They began to offer sacrifices to the stars1.

Step 2: Lies about Hashem. After time passed, people arose and told everyone that this is what Hashem wanted, they heard so from Him (false prophets).

Step 3: Lies about Idols. Deceitful people then took it further and said that the idols themselves spoke to them, and told them that they wish to be worshipped, in such and such ways. This step, when it spread throughout the whole world, was what made everyone forget God completely.

Step 4: Threats. As we see with what happened to Avraham in the court of Nimrod, they eventually would threaten those who refused to worship the idols with execution. Fear is a great tool at preventing truth from taking hold in a person's heart.

I strongly recommend learning the entire Rambam I linked and quoted, chapter 1.


1 what was the mistake? The mistake was that the stars and planets are likened to Hashem's ministers (which He of course honoured), but humans are Hashem's children. It's a corruption for the Prince to honour the minister. Hashem is offended when we go to one of His ministers to commune with Him. As His children, we should go direct to Him.

4
  • 1
    I'd like to separately note something amazing states by the Lubavitcher Rebbe , who asks why is this in a halachic work, rather than in the introduction, or in a history/philosophical work? The answer is that when it comes to Avodah Zara, you can't avoid it by simply not doing it. You are obligated to know exactly what the logical flaw is with Avodah Zara in order to fulfil the halacha
    – Rabbi Kaii
    Jan 20, 2023 at 14:29
  • Did they pray to Hashem as well as the stars? Is the idea that people just forgot that the origin of their praising the stars was Hashem - Thus eventually they were just praying directly to the stars? This in turn begs the question, how did they come to find “other gods,” outside of the stars and spheres, like that of fertility, war, etc..?
    – Eak2449
    Jan 20, 2023 at 15:34
  • 1
    @Eak2449 see edit
    – Rabbi Kaii
    Jan 22, 2023 at 17:17
  • 1
    @Eak2449 Yes, that is precisely what Rambam explains in Mishneh Torah concerning the development of idol worship. They first prayed to G-d and His Heavenly agents (Angels). But the emphasis is that in general there was a descent in literacy with each generation. This is an ongoing struggle for every generation, even today. Jan 22, 2023 at 21:06

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .