0

Concerning wedding ceremonies that may include idolatrous elements in which a gentile might be asked to participate due to family custom, Rabbi Moishe Wiener writes (in "The Divine Code"):

It is generally forbidden to participate in a wedding event that is held in a house of idol worship, or as a gathering in some other place, if the wedding ceremony is conducted through their priests, since they give praise and recognition to their idols. But if the ceremony is completely secular, and they only make a celebrating with a gathering in a social hall (not in the sanctuary that is used for their worship services), and there is no service of idols involved, it is permitted to participate, even if a priest is attending the event (footnote: clearly one may enter a house of idol worship for his own practical needs).

But if bad feelings, anger or hatred will arise if one does not participate in a wedding that is connected with idol worship - for example, if one's brother or sister is getting married in a house of idol worship, and most of the family will be participating - one is allowed to participate even if the others engage in idol worship in honor of the occasion. Obviously, an individual is forbidden to participate in any type of ceremony or prayer in which the idol is mentioned (footnote: See Shulchan Aruch Yoreh De'ah 148:9, 12).

I have two questions concerning this.

First, which propositions is the Shulchan Aruch being cited to support here (I have not found an English translation of this section)?

Second, the mention of "bad feelings, anger or hatred" seems to allude to some general principle of leniency not explicitly cited. To paraphrase: participation in aspects of such a ceremony that are not themselves worship can be justified so as to avoid causing animosity within the family. Where has this general principle articulated?

3
  • I am a bit confused with your question. Why would there be a halachic concern with a Gentile (non-Jew) participating in non-Jewish wedding? The quotes you use seem to be addressing a Jew participating in a non-Jewish wedding.
    – Dennis
    Aug 26, 2022 at 16:09
  • Gentiles are prohibited from practicing idolatry. It is one of the seven Noahide laws, and discussed extensively in the Talmud. Rabbi Wiener's book is subtitled "The Guide to Observing the Noahide Code" and discusses the halacha only insofar as it applies to gentiles.
    – EricFossum
    Aug 26, 2022 at 16:13
  • I am even more confused because everyone participating in the non-Jewish wedding is in the category of the "Gentile" in the title of your question. It might be better if you specified Ben-Noach or Noachide instead of Gentile since it is the seven noachide commandments and those who follow them that are the point of your question.
    – Dennis
    Aug 26, 2022 at 19:48

0

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .