8

I was taught in yeshiva that as a young man, Rambam just studied Torah and was supported by his brother, who was a jewel merchant. Then his brother died at sea, so Rambam became a physician.

Some therefore claim that when the Rambam wrote that it is absolutely forbidden for one to say "I will just study Torah and not get a job", that doesn't apply if your family supports you, because the Rambam did that!

Recently someone told me that no, Rambam was never a "professional Torah student." His brother did the hard work of sailing the seas to obtain the jewels wholesale, and Rambam had a fairly calm job retailing them -- but he was still working.

Does anyone have sources on this, please?

  • The part of this that is potentially on topic is "[was Rambam a professional Torah student or did he work too]" which is a question about how he practiced Judaism, not details about "What financial arrangement did Rambam have with his jeweler brother?" – Double AA Aug 14 at 13:35
6

These Hebrew sites cite a letter from Rambam to Eliyahu the Dayan (Igrot Rambam, Rav Shilat Press, Volume I p. 311; emphasis added):

והרעה הגדולה שבאה עליי באחרונה, ...והיא פטירת הצדיק, שטבע בים הודו ובידו ממון רב לי ולו ולאחרים והניח בת קטנה ואלמנתו אצלי..והוא היה האח. והוא היה התלמיד והוא היה הנושא ונותן בשוק ומרוויח, ואני הייתי יושב לבטח...והלך לחיי העולם, והניחני נבהל בארץ נוכריה.

And the greatest tragedy that recently befell me was the death of the righteous one who drowned in the Indian Ocean while holding a great deal of property of mine, his, and others', leaving me with his young daughter and widow, namely my brother. He was a student, he would do business in the markets and make profits while I dwelled securely ... he has gone to Eternal Life, leaving me confounded in a strange land.

So his brother had "money of his", "and did business while leaving me secure." I guess there are several ways that can be read:

  • He had money that he had -- pledged to me? Owed me? Because he was supporting me?
  • He had money that I had invested with him.
  • He "left me secure" because he paid all the bills, or because he took care of the major risks?
  • " והוא היה הנושא ונותן בשוק ומרוויח, ואני הייתי יושב לבטח". Sounds like the brother did the work of retailing them in the market. – IsraelReader Oct 10 '18 at 20:28
5

See here:

However, some ask, did not the Rambam do precisely that? Did he not learn Torah while his brother, David, worked as a merchant and supported him? Only after his brother died tragically did Rambam start working.

...

The answer seems to be that this is not true.

...

It was customary in merchants' families that one member, usually a father or elder brother, stayed put and the others traveled. Labrat and Judah (like Moses and David Maimonides later) had divided the family business between themselves in such a way.

It seems that this rests on supposition, based on what was common in those days.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .