I saw in the Artscroll Talmud, Tractate Bava Basra, at the very end of 25A:

The Gemara quotes a Baraisa concerning the path of the sun: A Baraisa has taught: R' Eliezer says: The world resembles a pavilion, in that it is enclosed on three sides and open on the fourth; - and the northern side is not enclosed......

[Maharal (Chidushei Aggados) maintains that the Gemara here is not discussing the actual astronomical phenomena, but a metaphysical concept couched in astronomical language; see there for his detailed explanation (see also his Be'er HaGolah, Be'er 6).]

........This brings us back to R' Eliezer. The Baraisa resumes. What is the meaning of the verse which states: From the inner chamber comes the whirlwind - this refers to the south wind, which comes from the innermost region of the world; and from the dispersed parts, the cold - this refers to the north wind, which comes from the open side of the world. The Baraisa continues with an exposition of the next verse. By the Breathe of G-d He gives ice - this refers to the west wind; and an expanse of water in a torrent - this refers to the east wind.

If anyone could possibly provide the Maharal's detailed explanation of this Gemara in Chidushei Aggados and in Be'er Hagolah, Be'er 6, in English, I would appreciate it very much.

  • His explanation is rather complicated. There's an artscroll book on Beer HaGolah I bet it's explained properly there.
    – robev
    Apr 3, 2022 at 4:51
  • You have to understand the Maharal's concept of North, South, East and West, first. (The Maharal understands that these are fundamental aspects of the briah and not just directions.)
    – pcoz
    Apr 3, 2022 at 6:18


You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .