0

Posting for someone else:

The Rashbam on Bereshis 22:1 brings that Hashem, in retaliation for Avraham giving 7 sheep to Avimelech, says that Avimelech's descendants will destroy 7 sanctuaries of Avraham's descendants; the mishkan, Givon, Nov, Shiloh, Gilgal and the First and Second Temples.  How is this possible, given that the First and Second Temples were destroyed by the Babylonians and Romans respectively, and they were not descendants of Avimelech, who was a Philistine?

2
  • 2
    Note it is generally agreed that the Plishtim of Avimelech were not the same people as the ones we find later on in Tanach.
    – Harel13
    Commented Feb 1, 2022 at 6:30
  • My guess is that it is enough if they were partial descendants. So somewhere in both their lineages were descendants of Avimelech, but that does not mean they were actually members of the Philistines.
    – N.T.
    Commented Feb 1, 2022 at 9:08

1 Answer 1

2

The Rashbam is citing Midrash Shemuel 12.1. Midrash Shemuel is a later work (first cited by Rashi) which collates earlier rabbinic material (such as Bereshith Rabbah). So really the question ought be on the text as transmitted by the Midrash Shemuel. In the chapter on Midrash Shemuel in Ginze Midrash (by Zvi Meir Rabinowitz) p. 187 fn. 58 he writes:

שני בתי המקדש הראשון והשני לא נחרבו ע"י הפלשתים אבל תולה חורבנם בחטאו של אברהם שכרת ברית עם אבימלך. בב"ר נד ד עמ' 580 חסרה המלה 'בניו' ומובא 'כנגדו מחריבין מבניך'

The First and Second Temples were not destroyed by the Philistines, however their destruction was contingent upon the sin of Abraham who forged a covenant with Abimelekh. In Gen. Rabbah 54 4, p. 580, the word "his sons" is absent, and brought in its stead are the words "opposite him your sons will be destroyed".

So it would appear that in earlier iterations, such as in Bereshith Rabbah, it is not suggested that the Philistines are descended from Abimelekh. Rather that the Midrash Shemuel introduced an error in the transmission of this midrash from Bereshith Rabbah, and that the Rashbam merely preserved the text as he received it.

2
  • 2
    Are there manuscripts of Bereshit Rabba that have the word בניו? If you (or Rabinowitz) haven't checked then you can't say for sure who introduced the alleged error
    – Double AA
    Commented Feb 1, 2022 at 17:49
  • 1
    @DoubleAA Rabinowitz is citing Albeck's critical edition of Bereshith Rabbah based on his analysis of the available manuscripts. You can check it out for yourself here: archive.org/details/bereschitrabba02albe/page/581/mode/2up Commented Feb 1, 2022 at 18:44

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .