2

If a divorce GET (document) is written on loose sand in a box and delivered to the woman, is this a kosher GET and valid divorce?

The writing would hold in the sand, though if the box holding the sand is tipped too much to one side, the get would be erased.

1
  • 4
    There would be 3 issues to consider. 1. It’s being written with something that isn’t long lasting which according to many, is passul. 2. It’s being carved out instead of written, which is not recommended according to Rama 125:4. 3. Assuming there are witnesses to confirm the writing at the time of giving it, the Rama 124:2 brings some who say if it's written on something that doesn’t last it’s passul
    – Chatzkel
    Oct 3 at 2:04
2

The Rambam in Hilchos Gerushin 4:1 writes that things that don't leave a permanent impression cannot be used such as drinks ,fruit juice and similar type items. The Mishna in shabbos 12:5 writes that writing on sand(see Bartanura who explains that is what avak derachim is)would be patur from the issur of writing on shabbos. It seems from these sources that sand would not be a valid means of writing a get.

Text from Taz 125:1 :שרישומו ניכר פירוש הרושם מתקיים וניכר תמיד לאפוקי מדבר שאינו מתקיים כמו משקין ומי פירות

See also the the Bach on the Tur siman 125 which discusses a possible difference between the the Tur and the Rambam whether one needs just to recognize the letters or that it needs to be permanent as well.

3
  • 1
    Sand does leave a permanent impression as long as you don't wipe it away, unlike fruit juice that disappears of its own accord when it dries.
    – magicker72
    Oct 3 at 16:17
  • With a slight wind sand can move
    – sam
    Oct 3 at 17:17
  • 1
    @magicker the mishna in shabbat as understood by bartenura indicates that is not considered permanent, at least as regards the laws of shabbat
    – Double AA
    Oct 3 at 20:08
1

The first thing that needs to be clarified is ON what was it written. I'm assuming you are talking about a scenario where the sand is carved out of sand sitting in a box, not a case of using sand to write letters on a klaf.

According to the Rama 124:2 it should be written ON something that has lasting power;

וי"א דוקא בדבר שהוא של קיימא אבל אם כתב בעלה של בצלים או ירקות וכדומה לזה פסול (הר"ן פ"ב)

Writing on (or in) sand, is debatable if it can be considered lasting.

Another point to consider is how the letters are formed. If they carved out (as my assumption) then perhaps it would be good, however if they are embossed it would be problematic. The Shulchan Aruch 125:4 mentions this

חקק גט על הלוח או על האבן או על טס של מתכת אם חפר יריכי האותיות כשר וכן אם חקק יריכי האותיות מאחורי הטס עד שבלטו בפני הטס אבל אם חפר תוך האות עד שיראו היריכות גבוהות מכאן ומכאן או שהכה על פני הטס בחותם עד שנמצאו האותיות בולטות כדרך שעושין דינר זהב אינו גט: הגה י"א דלכתחילה יש להחמיר שלא לכתוב בקולמוס של ברזל שלא לבא לידי חקיקה (סדר גיטין) וע"ל סי' זה סעיף כ"ב ולא מקרי חק תוכות אלא כשכל האות נעשה כך אבל אם צריך עדיין לתקן שיהיה אות כשר (ת"ה סי' רכ"ח)

Finally, there is the main issue of writing with something that is not long lasting. The cases that are used as examples in Shulchan Aruch and elsewhere, are about fruit juices and the like, things that will fade on their own over time. Sand, if left alone will remain as is. However, since it can be easily erased, there will have to be witnesses at the time of giving that will attest to what was written. Yet, we can perhaps learn from Hilchos Shabbos where the poskim include sand as the same as fruit juice

The Shulchan Aruch 340:4 says that one should not write in fruit juices or ashes, the Mishna Berura 340:20 mentions that the same issur would apply to sand. So, for Shabbos, writing in sand would be assur M'drabbanan, just like fruit juices.

There might be another point to consider from Hilchos Shabbos, that since it is only assur M'drabbanan it is not good enough for a Get;

The Gemara in Gittin 19A says in the name of R' Yochanon;

א"ל והלא לימדתנו רבינו כתב עליון כתב לענין שבת א"ל וכי מפני שאנו מדמין נעשה מעשה

Rashi there explains that even on Shabbos, such a writing would not bring a Korban. Seemingly, a ksav that is only assur M'drabbanan on Shabbos is not good enough for a Get.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .