When did Rosh Hashanah begin? According to a scientific observation, the sliver of moon was first sighted on Tuesday night. My understanding is that Rosh Hashanah begins at the appearance of such. Is it correct that Rosh Hashanah really began on Tuesday night? Is it a mistake to celebrate a day too early?

1 Answer 1


In the days of the Talmud, witnesses would report to the Sanhedrin that they saw the new moon, and then the court would declare that the month started. Even if the court knew that the moon should be visible, if no witnesses came, they would wait until the next day to make it Rosh HaShanah or Rosh Chodesh.

When the sage Hillel Nesiah saw that there would no longer be a court, he instituted a calendar system on a nineteen year cycle, and declared the starts of the month in perpetuity. Therefore, we no longer rely on direct observation of the moon to decide our calendar, and it would be a mistake to celebrate a day early.

This is all discussed at length in Tractate Rosh Hashana and Maimonides' Laws of Kiddush Hachodesh. Specifically, he writes:

And this matter is a law of Moses from Sinai: That at a time that there is a Sanhedrin, we set [the new month] by sighting; and when the Sanhedrin does not exist, we set [it] according to this calculation that we [use] to calculate today, and we are not concerned about the sighting. Rather, sometimes the day we set with this calculation will be the day of sighting; [and sometimes it will be] a day before it, or a day after it.

  • @n-t, please put a clickable link for your source.
    – ninamag
    Sep 9, 2021 at 10:03
  • @n-t, you wrote, "it would be a mistake to celebrate a day early" - can you clarify this, please. We (all of us who follow the rabbinics) did "celebrate a day early", in that we celebrated before we "saw the new moon".
    – ninamag
    Sep 9, 2021 at 10:04
  • 1
    @ninamag I see what you mean. The point is that the actual holidays and months are determined by the Court, and the time of the new moon is just a detail. Sometimes Rosh Chodesh can be a day after the moon, but that is its time.
    – N.T.
    Sep 9, 2021 at 10:20

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .